Critiquing Durans resume

That was my impression last time I saw it and I'm not alone in thinking it (if Duran took one more round on the cards he would have won). I'll rewatch it and see if my opinion changes if I score it RBR.

Point is it was Hagler, and it was CLOSE.[/quote] this is the kind of insanity i'm talking about....

- leonard and duran fight to a virtual draw in the first fight, and idiots like this want to say duran dominated.

- hagler dominates duran for 15 rounds and idiots like this want to say it was close and duran was robbed.

can't argue with dumba88

 

best person to compare duran's career with is actually ssm.

- both lw champs. duran had 12 defenses, ssm had 8. duran lost to dejesus, shane remained undefeated.

Comparison: ssm better at lw.

- both jumped to ww. duran won a decision over srl. ssm won a decision over odlh. srl fought with a handicap

Comparison: ssm's win is more meaningful than duran's.

- both lost their ww titles. duran quit against srl, ssm lost to vernon forrest.

Comparison: ssm went out like a champ...duran went out like a punk. ssm wins.

- both moved up in weight and challenged for the jmw title. duran lost to benitez, beat moore and got poleaxed by hearns. ssm beat dlh and lost to winky.

Comparison: DLH is better than moore. winky is equal to or better than benitez... ssm wins.

- duran challenged hagler and lost a decision.
Comparson: not applicable.

among the lesser champs, duran beat palomino, cuevas, moore and barkley. shane beat vargas, collazzo, mayorga, margarito and in my opinion, Cotto.
Comparison: ssm wins.


Conclusion: overall, the two had similar trajectories to their career and a lot in common...however ssm had better overall success and therefore ranks higher....

 

i don't get it...are my feelins supposed to be hurt? :think

 

since when did we need to compare fmj to anyone for posters on esb to discredit him? they do that as a matter of course.

 

dude, you're just making excuses for duran being obliterated by hearns.

lemme ask you this...do you think it's EVER possible that being the shorter guy might be at an advantage?

I don't think you know what a "physical advantage" is.