Current Top 10 P4P List

Your Top 5 is perfect.

6-10 sucks.

 

Mosley is too high.

 

Mosley was not in anyone's top 20 and considered old. Then one fight and he is in top 5?

No, he is not and he is a cheater. He should not be in any fan's P4P list.

 

I revise my list.

1. Manny Pacquiao
2. Juan Manuel Marquez
3. Bernard Hopkins
4. Paul Williams
5. Miguel Cotto
6. Chad Dawson
7. Shane Mosley (should probably be like 8 )
8. Wladimir Klitschko
9. Juan Manuel Lopez
10. Lots of people can go here.

 

Till he isn't caught, he isn't a cheater. Like Holyfield, Tyson, Trinidad etc.

 

he admitted to it.

 

There's not really 10 fighters worthy of P4P status..........Just call it the best 10 fighters in the world..

Paul Williams has done NOTHING and would not be ranked at any other time in the sport; Bernard has MAYBE has 1 fight left and is not even active.

 

1. JMM
2. Pacquiao
3. Hopkin
3. Williams
5. Cotto



Can only do a Top 5 with any certainty, 6-10 is very open

 

Interesting point

Me and Eze have pretty much the same top 5, but your right saying Hopkins and Williams activity doesnt warrant placing so high. I did put them there in terms of how good they are

For someone as avoided as Williams though, maybe its the only fair thing to do

 

:good

I just can't put Mosley higher than 6. Even 6 I feel is too high.

Williams can probably go to 3 because Hopkins has been VERY inactive.

 

He thought that those were vitamins :yep

Since De La Hoya fights I havent heard new accusations...doping sucks, concrete in gloves also

 

No. He admitted that he took EPO. He pointed out the days on a calendar to the FBI in which he took EPO.

 

KCD, How can you have a win against a 'future' champ, what on earth does that mean?

I have read all 3 pages now and poster after poster have said withy considerable justification Mosely should not be so high and yet dumb poster after dumb poster keep putting him at 5th place.

Mosley was losing against Mayorga in my view and achieved a Froch style KO, if Mosely is top 5, then he is equal with Froch!

Mosely had one dominant performance against a cheat, apart from that there is no real reason why his 'current' level of ability makes him the 5th best boxer on the planet.

 

Never knew that. I heard that he took that **** unwittingly. Now it's hard for me to rate him...hope that in recent years (Vargas, Cotto, Mayorga, Margarito) he has been clean...