1.pacquiao 2.mayweather 3.martinez 4.Marquez 5.Klitschko 6.Donaire 7.bradley 8.hopkins 9.gamboa 10.cotto
1- Pac 2 Mayweather 3 Martinez 4 JMM 5 Wlad 6 Doniare 7 Ward 8 Bradley 9 Froch 10 Hopkins 11 Segura 12 Wonjongkam 13 Guerrero 14 Khan 15 Gamboa
I don't have time to compare all of them. How about Larry Donald vs. Sultan Ibragimov? Sultan gets credit for beating Briggs who was in worse shape than for the Vitali fight. He has a draw with Ray Austin. A win over Whitaker, 44 year old Holyfield. A nearly 39 year old Larry Donald beat Valuev more impressively than prime David Haye. A 38 year old Larry Donald had a draw with Ray Austin. Beat a 42 year old Holyfield easier than Ibragimov. Beat a 39 year old but still viable Tim Witherspoon (as evidenced by the Ray Mercer fight). He lasted the distance with prime Riddick Bowe who was trying to take his head off with every shot, not a timid Wlad (on account of how Haye is praised for going the distance with Wlad :nut). Haye is maybe slightly better than Herbie Hide. Maybe.
pacman pbf martinez hopkins wlad donaire vitali ward froch marquez bradley khan segura bute chris john. i base mine on boxers they have beaten. not how good they are.
1. Floyd (inactive for a year but has a legit fight coming up) 2. Pacquiao 3. Martinez 4. Wlad 5. JMM 6. Donaire 7. Hopkins 8. Vitali 9. Cotto 10. Ward 11. Froch 12. Bradley 13. Khan 14. Segura 15. Gamboa EDIT: With slight swaps here and there my list is almost identical to the OP's...
1. Manny Pacquiao 2. Floyd Mayweather Jr. 3. Sergio Martinez 4. Nonito Donaire 5. Wladimir Klitschko 6. Juan Manuel Marquez 7. Vitali Klitschko 8. Andre Ward 9. Timothy Bradley 10. Miguel Cotto 11. Bernard Hopkins 12. Pongsaklek Wonjongkam 13. Giovani Segura 14. Yuriorkis Gamboa 15. Carl Froch