PBF-JLC was a close fight and could have gone either way i'll give you that. I scored the fight 7-5 PBF but with that said PBF did the right thing and gave him an immediate rematch something Oscar wouldn't do against Pea or Ike. "Judah Up until the brawl" I can tell from that right there that you don't have clue as to what you're talking about. Up until the brawl??? :rofl PBF was walking down and kicking Zab's ass around the ring Zab was ready to go or quit that's why he fouled PBF. That whole part about Zab beating PBF up in that fight is a myth made up by PBF haters or people that don't know how to score a fight. The truth is Zab won 2 of the first 4 rounds at best and won the 12th. It was a near shutout for PBF from the 4th round on. You keep telling yourself that bull**** that a man with 5 losses against the elite and some big gifts will go down as the better fighter against a man who has a better record, better head to head, P4P # 1 longer and better all around boxer only in the eyes of a Oscarsexual would that be the case anyone who knows boxing won't agree.
Neither Mayweather or De La Hoya is done. I don't take Mayweather's retirement talks seriously, and De La Hoya ist still fighting. I'd like to wait until both careers are done to more fairly analyze the two.
I dont particularly like either, but i would definitely say DLH has a better legacy. Both in their prime it would be too close to call, with Oscar possibly winning a SD. PBF should fight the winner of Cotto/Maragarito if he wants to challenge DLH's legacy. And Zab Judah was getting the urine kicked out of him by PBF
Wow! Floyd fans are touchy when it comes to questioning his leagcy. Who sounds more like the (add boxers name)sexual here? Check out the fights they both had and see for yourself man. So by your standards is Joe Calzaghe a better fighter then Roy Jones Jr. He has a better win/ loss record.
Roy Jones was untouchable in his prime Oscar was beaten several times in his big difference there.:deal
I think the resume speak for themselves, while oscat had a lot tougher opposition, pbf had beaten everyone he sver stepped in the ring iwth, but oscar got jobbed a few times and got a gift agaisnt sturm, I think in the end if we take it right now, floyd is a lil better resume wise
welcome to amateur hour.... you list who floyd fought in his career at weights that mattered and i'll finish off the rest
Genaro Hernandez RTD8 Angel Manfredy KO2 Diego Corrales KO10 Jesus Chavez KO9 Jose Luis castillo UD Jose Luis Castillo UD Carlos Baldomir UD Ricky Hatton KO10