No Beating a guy who is not a top 500, or likely 1,000, ranked fighter in the world does not boost P4P stature. I mean, come on folks, what kind of stupid thread is this and what kind of stupid nonsense does the casual fan buy into?
That's actually a decent list, but I'd put Pongsaklek Wonjongkam, Toshiaki Nishioka or Segura ahead of him
1. Mayweather 2. Pacquiao 3. Donaire 4. Sergio 5. JMM 6. Wlad 7. Segura 8. Ward 9. Bradley 10. Vitali 11. Wonjongkam 12. Froch 13. Dawson 14. Hopkins 15. COTTO - exactly where he was going into today 16. Khan 17. Moreno 18. Gamboa 19. Nishioka 20. Bute 21. John
I like Cotto and I'm glad he got his revenge last night, he fought a brilliant fight. But hell ****ing no.
Of course Cotto should be in the P4P top 10 Maussa who became a world champ after Cotto beat him Ndou who became a world champ after Cotto beat him Torres who became a world champ after Cotto beat him Malinaggi who became a world champ after Cotto beat him Quintana who became a world champ after Cotto beat him Judah who became a world champ after Cotto beat him Mosely who became a world champ after Cotto beat him Foreman WBA LMW champ Clottey who relinquished his world title to make the fight Margarito rematch plus other world class/rated fighters Branco, Urkal, Pinto, Corley, Bailey etc Its not a bad run at all, I would say overall better than what Ward or Bradley have done to be in the P4P list. Obviously Cotto has a couple of losses but one is avenged and has contraversy and the other where he had to make a catch weight against the P4P #1