He royally ****s all of them up. Darchinyan would just get KOed again. Boxer counterpunchers will always be his weakness, and though he has improved, he isnt that monster he was at 115. Plus he is older now and he doesnt fight smart Mares-Uber talented kid, but Donaire is more experienced and just the better fighter in every aspect. Mares is too green. Maybe in 2 years it would be competitive, but not now Agbeko-Skilled and not outsized, but hittable. Donaire would slice him up like the rest. Agbeko seems to have a good chin, but he'd have trouble hitting donaire clean, and would probably get ripped with something halfway through the fight
one of the first smart things that you have ever said. I believe rematches should only be given if the fight is close and usually a controversial decision, a ko in the early or middle rounds is not grounds for a rematch.
Let's look at the common element, which is Darchinyan. Donaire ****ed Vic like a *****. Agbeko defeated Vic solidly. Mares only just beat Vic, and would have lost without low blows and poor refereeing. If it was as simple as A>B>C etc, then it would look like this: Donaire would defeat Agbeko, but he might have to work for it (like he did with an oversized Conception). Donaire would make Mares his *****, and do the same again to Darchinyan. If we throw out the A>B>C ****, then that is still how I would see it playing out.
Koki Kameda is that division now, so Donaire better watch his back. I hope Donaire takes on the Mares - Agbeko fight winner next.
I don't see how you can realistically predict anything but a Donaire KO against anybody at 118 right now.