Over the past 3 weeks ESB members have been listing there P4P top 10 to forulate the official Eastside Boxing Forum P4P top 10. [url]http://www.eastsideboxing.com/forum/showthread.php?t=246985&page=22[/url] If you voted a fighter number 1, they would recieve 10 points, if voted 2nd they would recieve 9 points and so on. 115 votes were taken in total. Lists deemed stupid or bias were not counted. IF YOU DIDN'T VOTE YOU HAVE NOTHING TO COMPLAIN ABOUT. The results are as follows; 1. Manny Pacquiao - 1108 2. Floyd Mayweather - 1071 3. Juan Manuel Marquez - 702 4. Sergio Martinez - 622 5. Wladamir Klitscko - 547 6. Paul Williams - 458 7. Andre Ward - 241 8. Miguel Cotto - 233 9. Nonito Donaire - 230 10. Tim Bradley - 160 11. Fernando Montiel - 148 12. Vitali Klitscko - 107 13. Juan Manuel Lopez - 98 14. Shane Mosley - 74 15. Jean Pascal - 63 16. Lucian Bute - 58 17. Chris John - 53 18. Bernard Hopkins - 50 19. David Haye - 42 20. Ivan Calderon - 33 (Has since lost. Segura will gain 50% of his points) 21. Tomasz Adamek - 30 22. Amir Khan - 23 23. Pongsaklek Wonjongkam - 18 24. Celestino Caballero - 17 25. Chad Dawson - 13 26. Andre Dirrell - 12 27. Andre Berto - 11 28. Rafael Marquez - 9 29. Yurorkis Gamboa - 7 30. Anselmo Moreno - 6 31. Mikkell Kessler - 5 32. Carl Froch - 4 32. Arthur Abraham - 4 32. Nkosinathi Joyi - 4 35. Vic Darchinyan - 2 35. Marco Huck - 2 37. Takioshi Nishioka - 1 37. Sergei Dzinzurik - 1 Analysis The biggest rise was for Andre Ward who jumped from 16 to 7. The biggest drop was Chad Dawson who dropped from 3 to 25. Only Pacquiao and Mayweather were in everybodys top 10, voted in the top 2 by everyone. This content is protected [url]http://www.eastsideboxing.com/forum/showthread.php?t=224146[/url]
I was one of them, i think he has prooved more than Pascal , i also think if it wasnt for the fight getting stopped Dawson was going to KO or get a TKO over Pascal , he just seemed to be ferocious and taking Pascal to teh topes in those later rounds.
I love the line - ''lists deemed stupid or bias will not be accepted'' So Dawson was #3 at one point :yikes
Montiel at 11? Pfft, I'm disgusted. He should be top 10 easy Suppose I can't complain though, since I didn't actually vote.
You can't really view the lower parts of the rankings as accurate. Its based on peoples top 10, although how some of those fighters made it into some top 10s puzzles me greatly. Only the top 15 or so should be looked at as the definitive list as I can see a case for all the fighters in the top 10.
I think the voting system should change. Bring a number of "boxing experts" give them 40 % of the total of 100 and leave just 60 % from the final voting points to the rest of the members. The "boxing experts" should be choose by vote in a thread were the members should choose 1 guy(picking yourself would be forbidden of course) they think is the best to be in the "P4P-rankings" jury. They should have 2000+ posts or higher.