HBO: Billy Joe Saunders vs. David Lemieux & Gary O'Sullivan vs. Antoine Douglas RBR.

A good number didn't give Lemieux a round. You and maybe one other guy did, that I saw.

My card, CST's, UTF's, qwerty's, Pinoy's, every other one that I've seen was a shutout.

 

And predictable.

 

But not the professional judges cards.

Maybe your having trouble with the meaning of the word "arguably ?"

 

I think I recall you calling Canelo-Mayweather a shut-out as well ?

 

Plenty of pro judges shouldn't be pro judges, and can't score fights properly. We all know this.

 

I did indeed. Still do, have re-watched a couple times.

 

I agree with this except bringing up Rosado getting robbed by Murray. Murray isn't the same guy anymore.

 

any sport with winners based upon judgement is rife for corruption. not that every sport isn't corrupt. just easier to fix judging than actual scoring.

 

I don't believe in/don't award "attaboy" rounds, which is why I'm far more qualified to score bouts than most.

This is the logic-trap fallacy that people fall into where the guy getting schooled does a little better than in all the other far more lopsided rounds while the one doing the schooling does a tad less well (or is just much less active, taking a breather, what have you) and so the mindless sheep thing to do is to give the guy that's been on the losing end a pity round/A-for-effort round. That isn't what you're supposed to do when properly, objectively scoring a fight RBR and viewing each round in a vacuum.

That's why I have both Mayweather vs. Canelo and BJS vs. Lemieux shutouts. There were rounds where the demonstrated gap in class was RELATIVELY narrower than in other rounds, but never a round where it narrowed enough that the master boxer didn't still deserve the 10-9.

 

Judging can be difficult, take the Parker vs Fury fight. Both WC's AJ and Wilder had Hughie winning, as did I. Professional judges had Parker winning, and plenty of posters here had him winning for pushing the action. Every person sees something different.

 

Stop this nonsense, even an Old Golovkin wins a UD vs Saunders, stop with this BS