Is GGG underrated or overrated?

Likethembigroundchunky · Jun 28, 2020

acie2g said: ↑

Haven’t gone through the whole thread but for me he falls on the scale of overrated especially from the die hards who claim he’s some atg that would destroy every fighter all time from 160-175 even though that has been proven false.

being honest with myself 160 has been very weak relative to other divisions for damn near a decade now in terms of greatness I’d probably rank it
1.Canelo
2.Martinez
3.Golovkin
From 2010-now
Canelo and Martinez I’d have to rank at the top because of their wins beating actual Champs for their titles both fighters beating the boogie man of their divisions (Williams/Chavez jr) for Marvella and (GGG) for Canelo
Martinez long reign as the legit Lineal Champ and THE MAN of the division until injuries took over and Canelo a fighter who may only have technically because of the title only fought 5 MW fights but in those 5 bouts, 4 were top 3 rated MW Champions he went 4-0-1 winning the Lineal, WBC 2x, WBA, & IBF titles at 160.
Golovkin I’d have to rank third because even those his overall resume is pretty trashy he’s beaten more bums then the rest of the guys ducking top champs so have to give him credit he does have 9 LEGITIMATE title defenses so being objective i feel that’s a fair ranking.

Head to head we saw Golovkin struggle with a career Jr MW in Canelo in his first 2 fights at 160,
And while injuries and the unexpected Cotto loss prevented a Marvella-GGG match up the fighter who had a disputed decision vs Williams that turned around and KO’d him in the rematch the same guy who damn near shut out Chavez in a masterclass would be all kinds of problems for Golovkin.

now just looking at him overall the guy underwhelmed as a competitor, I was a fan when he made his US debut the Stevens fight and the Knock out and his quote at the end of the fight, “I’m a bad boy, this is MY SHOW knock em down and knock em out”. Had me hooked and I thought he would be different from these all talk guys when he started with the 154-68 talk and that fighters were scared I bought into it. And then I saw Lara call him out and Trout, and Ward, saw Cotto offer him a catchweight, as well as Canelo and saw him balk even though all these fighters are vastly more accomplished than anybody he’s fought. Saw him almost lose who at the time was his best opponent in Jacobs over refusing to pay him a few extra dollars for the fight and lets be real jacobs is only thought of highly because he has an argument for beating or drawing with GGG because going into the fight he had struggled with and been dropped by the last 5/6 guys he’d fought outside of Quillin. The best guys he’s fought in Jacobs, Canelo, and I guess Dervy who again has done nothing going in but lose to Jacobs and is only considered a good fighter now because GGG arguably loss but in his 3 best opponents an argument can be made he lost in each fight. The guy has refused to move up in weight and is content fighting bums begging for a payday, at the end of the day while I’d say you have to respect him for doing a bit more to separate himself from guys like Quillin,Jacobs,Chavez at MW career wise that’s not really saying much but compared to the actual GREAT 160 fighters in SM and SA it’s a difference. Even in terms of style in the words of money may the kid is straight up and down no effects a decent power boxer but no real defensive great, nothing out of this word but his power vs not that great comp, defensively Martinez and Canelo are more fluid in their transitions evading and taking power off shoots even though Martinez was reckless at times.
Offensively as well both had a greater variety and arsenal Canelo has shown improvement in every fight for almost a decade which is impressive in its self his body punching and dynamic combination counter punching.
Martinez who was also a quality boxer a southpaw with power and an unorthodox style that was difficult to navigate. From style to legacy that’s just my breakdown on it but just one fans perspective.
Click to expand...

That needs punctuation.

acie2g · Jun 28, 2020

Likethembigroundchunky said: ↑

That needs punctuation.
Click to expand...

Cell phone man it’s put together enough that you can understand it lol

Log in or Sign up

Is GGG underrated or overrated?

Is GGG Underrated/Overrated?

Underrated

Overrated

Likethembigroundchunky Member Full Member

acie2g Boxing Junkie Full Member