Is Joe Calzaghe current top 3 P4P?

He has overtaken Pac at #2 now in my book.

 

Personally I don't think so. Kessler was a good fighter but never P4P material in his own right, and their fight was rather close.

Calzaghe can still get there but he has left the whole legacy thing a little late, though judging by his recent form, perhaps not too late.

 

2

 

2 major challengers in the last 5 years too...

 

Yes!

By all means . . . remove Winky's name in there and put JC at #3. Winky hasn't accomplished anything lately and JC deserve it more.

 

btw i got it
1. floyd
2. pac
3. hopkins

 

i'd put him at #3...either hiim or Cotto...

 

Yep

 

You could make a good case that he's top 5 but how can you put him above Mayweather, Pacquiao and Hatton?

 

He is a hair below Floyd and if Floyd loses, J.Calzage goes to # 1

 

Cal is #6.

Cotto just bumped him from 5th place.

1. Mayweather
2. Pacquiao
3. JMM
4. Hopkins
5. Cotto
6. Calzaghe

 

You're delusional.

 

If Floyd loses he'll have lost against Hatton who will of course go to number 1.

 

Why?...because I don't feel the same as you? He calls me delusional...what the ****'s wrong with you people...grow the **** up.

That's a proper ranking.

I guess this is just another example of people taking **** personal...the ****ing insecurity.

atsch

 

:huh :|