Is the p4p list meaningless?

Since no one really agrees to stipulations or criteria...or effin consistency FFS....any P4P list is just fantalk. Means ****all....

 

More weight equals more skill? That may be one of the weirdest takes ever.

 

Yes, bigger boxers are better at boxing by far than smaller boxers due to their weight

 

Technically yea

 

It's a good talking point but not good for much else.

 

Of course not, unless you think every division sans Heavyweight should be abolished.

Although why are people shitting on Americans for this? I mean Inoue is one of the biggest beneficiaries of this.

 

I like it. It’s a good and fun to compare and contrast fighters abilities and accomplishments regardless of the weight classes, praise them for what they bring to the ring whether they beat every other boxer alive or not.

If you think Dillian Whyte is a better boxer and deserves more praise and recognition than Roman Gonzalez, you’re a moron.

 

Because 0 Americans deserve top 5 and 1 deserved top 10 yet American rags put 5 different fighters in the top 10 regularly. Inoue is in those rankings because he deserves to be. Spence, Charlo, Stevenson, Tank are in those ratings because Americans will buy anything with an American flag on it

 

I look at it like it's the dynamite dozen. Like if you could rate baseball current top 12 regardless of positions. A current elite status that is always revolving.

 

It's over-referenced but attempts to do a good, meaningful thing.