I know it's a bit off topic, but if you think he should've been DQ'd for that on Soto, do you think there is a case for Barrera being DQ'd for dragging him across the ring and slamming his head into the turnbuckle? I didn't think the Soto incident was much worse. I wouldn't have given either of them as DQs though.
In answer to the original question, and apologies if this has already been said, but not since the start of internet boxing forums has any boxer not had a controversial fight in his career.
Even if we think so, there is still controversy, so, Roy Jones doesnt meet the criteria. I personally think every fighter has a moment, that is alittle less than 100% legit. We're in too objective a game.
Yeah Vitali was a good one. Tyson too if you are only counting wins/losses and not strange fights, then all his were the right decisions.