to put things into perspective. for any of you who think that calzaghe would take most of them need to remind yourselves which world class fighters has JC beaten in their prime. i guarantee you that britsh posters will be more liberal than the rest because, despite JC's excellent ability, he chose to live under warren's shadow and doesn't deserve to be compared to the likes of hopkins and toney in their prime because he never allowed himself to find out what he could really do.
Nice pics .. clearly you didn't hear the instruction to drink heavily then pick :fight in every fight except Jones.
vs. Roy Jones @ 168: Jones TKO vs. James Toney @ 168: Calzaghe SD vs. Mike McCallum @ 168: Calzaghe UD vs. Michael Nunn @ 168: Calzaghe UD vs. Chris Eubank @ 168: Calzaghe SD vs. Nigel Benn @ 168: Calzaghe UD vs. Steve Collins @ 168: Calzaghe TKO vs. Herol Graham @ 168: Calzaghe TKO vs. Gerald McClellan @ 168: Calzaghe UD
roy jones is the only one i can pick to beat JC Toney would be a very close fight and i think SD but JC getting it on volume and agression
Jones, Toney, McCallum and Eubank would have beat him fairly easy. I think that Jones would have stopped him. The others would have been toss ups. G-man, and Benn may have knocked him out, if not Joe would have likely won Dec. The rest I think that Joe would have won.
Presuming that this is all at SMW; 1. Roy Jones - RJJ 2. James Toney - Joe 3. Mike McCallum - Joe 4. Michael Nunn - Joe 5. Chris Eubank - Joe 6. Nigel Benn - Joe (but this being the toughest) 7. Steve Collins - Joe 8. Herol Graham - Joe 9. McClellan - Joe
1. Roy Jones - Jones KO 2. James Toney - Toney UD 3. Mike McCallum - McCallum UD 4. Michael Nunn - Nunn KO 5. Chris Eubank - Calzaghe UD 6.Nigel Benn - Calzaghe KO 7. Steve Collins - Calzaghe UD 8. Herol Graham - Calzaghe KO 9. G-Man - G-Man KO