Granted he did KO J-Rock in his next match, but since Ishe Smith rocked Julian a few times in their recent match, I think I'd just overrated Williams' chin. So I'm not sure how much that win was worth. Even then J-Rock was outboxing Charlo when he wasn't going down.
WBK SERIES 25: Boxing: Inoue KO5, Kimura Wide UD, Kyoguchi Wide UD, Taguchi CloseUD Oneirokritis: Inoue KO4; Kimura UD wide; Kyoguchi UD close; Taguchi UD close. Scores after 5 completed rounds: Oneirokritis: 48 1 Knockdown vs Pablinov: 47 1 Knockdown BoxingABC1: 46 2 Knockdowns vs DanielDimov: 46 2 Knockdowns Dontbscared TKO4 Jordank2406 KiwiMan: 46 vs Dfaulds: 49 2 Knockdowns Nellybc: 47 vs ChuckNorris: 50 6: 12/22 - Fatih Keles vs. Renald Garrido II - 10x3 WBO European Super Lightweight Title Oneirokritis: Keles UD Close vs Pablinov: BoxingABC1: Keles UD Close vs DanielDimov: KiwiMan: Keles UD Close vs Dfaulds: Nellybc: Keles MD vs ChuckNorris: Keles UD Close 7: 12/22 - Zakaria Attou vs. Orlando Fiordigiglio - 12x3 EBU Super Welterweight Title Oneirokritis: Attou SD vs Pablinov: BoxingABC1: vs DanielDimov: KiwiMan: Attou UD Close vs Dfaulds: Nellybc: Attou SD vs ChuckNorris: Attou MD 8: 12/30 - Ken Shiro vs. Gilberto Pedroza - 12x3 WBC World Light Flyweight Title Oneirokritis: Shiro KO 11 vs Pablinov: BoxingABC1: Shiro UD Close vs DanielDimov: KiwiMan: vs Dfaulds: Nellybc: vs ChuckNorris: 9: 12/30 - Naoya Inoue vs. Yoan Boyeaux - 12x3 WBO World Super Flyweight Title Oneirokritis: vs Pablinov: BoxingABC1: vs DanielDimov: KiwiMan: vs Dfaulds: Nellybc: vs ChuckNorris: 10: 12/31 - Sho Kimura vs. Toshiyuki Igarashi - 12x3 WBO World Flyweight Title Oneirokritis: vs Pablinov: BoxingABC1: vs DanielDimov: KiwiMan: vs Dfaulds: Nellybc: vs ChuckNorris: 11: 12/31 - Hiroto Kyoguchi vs. Carlos Buitrago - 12x3 IBF World Minimumweight Title Oneirokritis: vs Pablinov: BoxingABC1: vs DanielDimov: KiwiMan: vs Dfaulds: Nellybc: vs ChuckNorris: 12: 12/31 - Ryoichi Taguchi vs. Milan Melindo - 12x3 IBF & WBA World Light Flyweight Titles Oneirokritis: vs Pablinov: BoxingABC1: vs DanielDimov: KiwiMan: vs Dfaulds: Nellybc: vs ChuckNorris: RESERVE: 12/20 - Pipat Chaiporn vs. TJ Doheny - 12x3 / Doheny SD Oneirokritis: Doheny KO 9 vs Pablinov: Doheny UD Wide / 9-10 BoxingABC1: Doheny UD Close vs DanielDimov: Doheny UD Wide * default * / 10-10 KiwiMan: Doheny UD Wide vs Dfaulds: Doheny KO 8 / 9-10 Nellybc: Doheny UD Close vs ChuckNorris: Doheny UD Wide / 10-10
I think you might be underrating Trout, more than overrating Charlo. Trout's not an easy out for anyone (save Lara, who was just a horrible style match-up).
Yes I have never been very high on Trouts abilities. I often root for him, very likable person, just always saw him as a slightly above average fighter (relative to world class). So seems I am underrating him.... Time will tell. Will depend a bit what Charlo shows I think. Or if they have a rematch.