Marquez Vs Pac P4P King?

Lets suppose both win, who would you rate the #1 P4P king after winning their upcoming fight JMM or Pac?

 

depends how the fights go down really.

 

:rofl WHAT!?

Juan Manuel Marquez beats Floyd Mayweather, and Manny beats Ricky Hatton. We ALL know which is the better win there, unless Floyd comes in weight drained, and then that win ain't too great.

 

well then thats exactly my point. We don't know what the fight will look like do we?

 

Floyds the real P4P No.1 so if Marquez can beat him he's the new P4P king.

 

I doubt May is in bad shape and its not like he has been out the ring that long anyways.

 

As long as Pac defeats Hatton then he remains the p4p best no matter what happens in the JMM-PBF fight.

 

I have them tied for #1 ... I scored their latest fight a draw so I have them as equally great fighters.... BUT , if Pacman beats Hatton I would have him as the solid #1

 

Pac still.

Floyd coming off a long layoff.

 

So why doesn't that apply to hatton becoming # 1 P4P king if he beats pacman? atsch

 

But what if Marquez beats Mayweather lol. I think plenty of fans still regard May as the #1P4P even though he retired. So if Marquez beatst he real #1 king then hes regarded as #1. Just my thought.

 

pbf > hatton

so if jmm manages to win against floyd, then he's my no.1

 

even if jmm beats pbf, pac still has 2 wins over him, and a win over hatton.

in order for jmm to be p4p #1, hell have to beat pacman, or pac will have to lost/retire. simple as that.

 

MArquez beating Mayweather is much more impressive than Pac beating Hatton of course... I would have Marquez above Pac if Marquez beat PBF. I don't really think Marquez can beat PBF, not because of skill... just because of size.

 

even if mayweather had not retired pacman would be p4p num 1