More punches vs Accurate punches

Fighter A: 202/1163 19%
Fighter B: 225/763 29%



Fighter A wins 116-112 on all scorecards. Bonus points if you know who the fighters are.

 

it depends. i would give more weight on power punches rather than potshot jabs with higher percentage.

 

Fights are scored via judging a fighters Ring Generalship, Clean punching, Affective Aggression and Defense. Not punch stats. It also matters more how the punches are applied throughout 12 rounds including KDs and Point Deductions. Either fighter could of won it.

Looking at the stat though, I wouldn't award Fighter A great affective aggression because he missed a lot of punches and his defense was worse because he took in higher percentage of punches.

Fighter B landed only a couple less over 12 rounds but had to of shown more generalship and affective aggression to land higher percent punches and possibly better defense for 503 punches to miss him.

 

can you break them down into power punches and jab percentages as well? also is this with a different opponent or stats if they fought each other? if for a different opponent, it's hard to judge based on styles of the opponent but if it were stats when they fight each other, the one with the more punches connected usually wins especially if it was distributed in different rounds.

 

i'd like to know what kind of punches we are talking about...jabs? straight rights, lefts, hooks, power shot or pot shots?

if fighter A landed 100 power shots and figher B landed 50, i'm going with fighter A every time...not to mention there are other factors such as KD's, KO's, ect...

stat's can be skewed to whatever point you want to prove. just give me the facts, meaning what was more significant...

 

Obvious is obvious.

Lets also point out that the fighter thats being punched had won two major KO victories pre-fighter B fight, meanwhile, pre-fighter A he'd arguably LOST two bouts, one against SERGIO MORA.

 

Fighter B, because based solely on the numbers alone, fighter B showed better defense and punch selection...but, as others have stated, there is alot more that goes into scoring a fight than just the total punches landed.

 

how do you get that? :huh

 

Well we really can't base a fight solely on stats we have to watch it and I give a big :-( to those who give fights to those with the most missed/non scoring punches throughout the course of the fight.

Alexander-Kotelnik? Most had Kotelnik winning which he should've. He was the better ring general after the first 4 rounds and landed the better shots.

 

Simple, Fighter A was hit with everything that was thrown his way (pretty much), whereas Fighter B was not as easily hit, and was able to time/figure out his opponent to the point where most of what he threw landed.

 

In most cases I think accuracy trumps amount landed

i mean if you throw 1000 punches you should land at least 300 hundred right just by volume

im more impressed by the guy who doesnt have to throw a lot of punches to land a lot of punches

you can have a guy like fighter B only throw in the 400's to get over 200 landed

of course power and and ring generalship and knockdowns or deductions come into effect

contradictions

if the accurate fighter B only comes on late like Hopkins vs Taylor 2

if out of the 208 landed 100 are in the last few rounds it means the busy guy won like 5 or 6 rounds and probably wins the whole fight

examples of output vs accuracy

Hopkins vs Taylor I, I score for Bernard the accuracy guy

Valuev vs Haye, I scored for Valuev the output guy, Haye the accuracy guy was accurate and had power but threw to few punches and running around the ring took away ring generalship

Hopkins vs Taylor II, scored for Taylor the busy fighter, Hopkins was very accurate but like I said above he was accurate but didnt land or come on til late

Calzaghe vs Hopkins, I scored for Calzaghe the busy fighter, Hopkins the accurate guy just didnt do enough

Williams vs Wright, I had it for Williams but was not impressed Winky landed at a high volume and blocked many of Williams punches but you just couldnt really give Wright a round cause Williams just smothered him with shots if Wright had power he may have had some rounds on my card

 

oh and I had the accurate Kotelnik win over Alexander

 

And where does it show in the stats how many times fighter A or B was punched?

Or are you suffering the signs of a crack smoking mother?

 

Hmmmm...I'm assuming the TS is referring to a fight between fighters A and B, no?

 

http://www.secondsout.com/ringside/...ing-professional-boxing-for-the-tv-boxing-fan

Tom Kaczmarek - Chairman of WBC officials board

Most of judging a fight is the subjective analysis. Quantity of punches is not the most important thing, the power and quality of the punch matters aswell.