I like Tommy Hearns as well in there. He really could box defensively if he wanted. Had rediculous power, fast hands and utilized his height pretty well considering his style. Still Amazing watching him outbox SRL moving backwards and moving. He really had another dimension to his style when it came to survival mode. His only problem was he could get caught cleanly.. I wonder how things would have gone with Hagler had he not broken his hand and fought defensively. But yeah, Roy was sick. He was pure talent, reflexes, quickness and contingency. Hamed was no slouch when it came to talent, very unorthodox as well.
Oleg Saitov was the most talented fighter of all time IMO.He lacked firepower,but hell he could fight like the personification of God in gloves inside a box ring.
Of course, any thinking boxing fan knows that the "most talented" boxer does not always equate to the "best boxer". There are less naturally gifted fighters who compensate by having superior brains, technique and skills that can just as easily negate supior "gifts'. Examples I am sure will be forthcoming.
My vote goes for RJJ and Tyson during their primes it looked like no one could come close to beating them.
Wilfredo Gomez fascinates me in that in the seventies, up until the time he fought Sanchez, was an almost perfect fighter with catlike gifts of cunning, spees, boxing ability and above all a killer punch. He could do it all. Combinations, an almost outerspacelike contempt and coldness in the way he would dispatch his poor opponents. Just look at the fight with Zarate as the classic example. Unbelievable.
Jones never fought the quality of fighters that PBF has fought. Never. The best fighter RJJ fought was Toney and that fight is infamous in the fact that it was the same Toney that fought Dave Tiberi and Montell Griffin. Maybe PBF has lost rounds, but his quality of opposition was much better. Mayweather lost rounds to Castillo, while Jones was losing a fight to Montell Griffin. Now do you consider Griffin better to Castillo?
Jones has fought BETTER overall opposition than Floyd Mayweather Bernard Hopkins James Toney Mike McCallum Virgil Hill Antonio Tarver Clinton Woods Reggie Johnson Lou Del Valle Vinny Pazienza Thulani Malinga Otis Grant Eric Lucas Jorge Fernando Castro Montell Griffin John Ruiz Eric Harding Julio Cesar Gonzalez Glen Kelly David Telesco In that resume alone, there is 3 all time greats. Floyd has only fought one. Hopkins is better than De La Hoya, Toney is better than Castillo, McCallum is better than Corrales, and Hill is better than Judah, Hernandez, or Manfredy. Jones defeated 17 world champions, 5 more than Mayweather's 12 In the Toney fight, Roy's movement, usage of angles, and handspeed befuddled Toney, preventing him from getting into a rythm and preventing him from getting off to counterpunch. Roy was simply not there to be hit and was too fast for James. James couldn't deal with the speed. Jones was a stylistic nightmare for James Toney. That was not the Toney who came into the Thadzi and Griffin fights - that was a motivated Toney who was beat by the better fighter. Jones had Griffin out, but was disqualified for hitting him when he was down. And look what happened in the rematch...Montell was out in 1. Jones fought the better fighters, had the better resume, and was the more talented fighter.
On paper, of course these guys look better, but most of the fighters he fought weren't in their primes at all. McCallum was 40 going on 50, and losing more than he was winning. Grant was shopworn and coming up from Middleweight to Light Heavy. Pazienza was a circus act and never a top flight Super Middleweight. Hill lost to an old, bloated, past his prime Hearns years before he fought RJJ. Reggie Johnsons best years were clearly behind him. With this said. RJJ never fought these guys when they were at their best. B-Hop was still a crude brawler, and not even close to the fighter he is today. The same goes for Clinton Woods, who is a much better fighter. The other guys you mentioned, like John Ruiz, are second rate ham-n-eggers. Glen Kelly, Dave Telesco? Come on, man! They suck! PBF has beaten 12 champions and counting, and is not even close to being done. Hatton will make 13. Angel Manfredy Genaro Hernandez JC Castillo Diego Corrales Oscar de la Hoya Zab Judah Arturo Gatti Sharba Mitchell Carlos Baldimar Chop Chop Corley Jesus Chavez Goyo Vargas Famoso Hernandez
You can say that about a lot of fighters, but Castillo beat Stevie Johnston, Corrales, Casemeyor, and other top fighters. He was an excellent fighter.