My Current Top 10 P4P List

Resaonable/non-troll lists are something along these lines:

1. Mayweather (step 1)

2. Marquez/Ward (step 2)

4. Donaire/Martinez (step 3)

6. Pacquaio (step 4)

7. Wlad (step 5)

8-10. Broner/Froch/Mares/Vilora/Bradley (step 6)


A step either way, up or down 1 from this is acceptable, given explanation. Any more deviation is pushing it.

 

This is very reasonable, I say Ward is a lock at #2 though and JMM is in step 3. I would put wlad in the step 6 and add a couple of names including Rigo . . . but over all a very solid framework.

 

hahahahah Rios, Rigo!!!! terrible, Rios isn't even top 50 p4p. Money Abril should be top 5 in that case cause he won 11 of 12 rds vs Rios

Viloria shouldn't be in there either. No way is Nonito higher than #5, no way should Pac be above Martinez.

this is the worst **** i've ever seen, I could give a list of the top 50 boxers to someone that doesn't watch the sport and get them to select 10 boxers at random and it would be as good or better than this ****.

 

I am tired and sick of seeing so many great Mexican fighters being ignored on websites like these that are supposed to give knowledge bout the real champions. i have not compiled together a very big list yet myself but they would have to include such winners as Jose Carlos Rodriguez, Armando Garcia and Gibran Medino not to mention of course Erik Morales though the boxing community continues to try to speak badly to his name.

 

*honestly...i don't like Ward, but just look at the list of fighters he's beaten...he has to be #1.

 

I have issues placing Rigondeaux anywhere near a top 10 pound for pound list, no matter how subjective it is. The guy's best win is a tough decision over Ricardo Cordoba for goodness sake.

Rios shouldn't be anywhere near either. Acosta, Antillon, Murray and Alvarado are decent wins, but he is quite one dimensional, hence the fact he is very rarely pitted with stylists these days.

Other than that I have no major complaints. I disagree about having Donaire and Ward ahead of Mayweather and JMM, but there you go.

 

atsch

 

I see that you do not watch boxing . . . well that explains your P4P list

 

*Abril was robbed..Rios lost and i don't mean maybe.

 

I agree with the overall sentiment of what you are saying but I hope these are not the guys you are talking about:bbb

 

agreed :good

 

manny pacquiao ahead of Sergio or Wlad? Huh? Brian Viloria? Brandon Rios? Rigo?

Not to mention your top 3 are probably out of order.

 

I've got pac after Wlad. He's been inactive forever and hasn't looked impresive in quite some time. Wlad is certainly higher than manny at this point imo.