These lists are too hard to make, maybe in time Ill make one too, but for everyone else if you hate his list, make one yourselves or stfu.
Nobody here is knocking the list because as you say,they're hard to make and they're also very subjective.People are just adding their own opinions
Darchinyan should be higher and Valuev shouldn't be in the top 100 he's the worst Heavyweight champion I've ever seen. I like your top ten though.
de la hoya is only part time fighter but would be fair if he scraped top 100 agreed valuev shouldnt be in there but great list
valuev has gotta be in the simply for his win records agaisnt top 10 guys, which as controversial as it is he has. (i personally gave him the verdict agaisnt evander, trust me watch without commentary). de la hoyas on losses of the past 2 years was agaisnt the 2 best fighters
I'm not sure if i had commentary or not - but even so, I was positive that was Holyfield's fight - do you have any links to it? I quite enjoyed it - it was like a lesser version of Hopkins/Pavlik for me
That list has a LOT of bold mistakes. I really am wondering right now if the posters who praised it actually follow the sport... Props for taking the time to try and put something together like that (personally i have better things to do with my time). Unfortunately you missed the mark by a bit. I'll run through a list of things i would have differently shortly.
Good job dude! Id find it impossible to compose a current top 100 p4p right now! Just looking at your top 10, id rate Cotto over Williams and Hatton over Calderon. Wouldn't say it was wrong how you ranked them though.