1. Floyd Mayweather Jr 2. Manny Pacquiao 3. Chad Dawson 4. Paul Williams 5. Juan Manuel Marquez 6. Shane Mosley 7. Rafael Marquez 8. Sergio Martinez 9. Wladimir Klitschko 10. Lucien Bute 11. Juan Manuel Lopez 12. Timothy Bradley 13. Nonito Donaire 14. Bernard Hopkins 15. Yuriorkis Gamboa
STFU you nob, stop sucking his **** just because hes BLACK. putting him at no#3 is criminal his only good win is against Adamek, beating an ancient Johnson (that lost to Clinton Woods)and a shot Tarver dont cut it in top 5 P4P im afraid:hi: IDIOTIC
Your list is ****in horrible. How the **** could anybody have gamboa top 15 p4p? I like him but he hasnt beaten anybody yet and looked awful in his last fight versus another nobody. Explain to me like to 5 year old how is he more deserving than the likes of Adamek , Vitaly even David "excusemaker" Haye?
After Pwill's last two outings he doesn't deserve to even be in the top 10 and no way SM is 11. SM should be around 7-8. Dawson is also extremely overrated. It takes more than an 0 to be in the higher echelons of P4P. Beating Adamek was good but beating an ancient Tarver and two snoozefests with Glen Johnson, who is simply a dangerous journeyman whom you can never underestimate, is not nearly enough to be in the top 5 P4P.
Jaffay, Perez is really still in after his performance last night?? Otherwise, the list looks good, I really respect you putting John above Lopez, any other way is criminal.
This is loaded with agenda. Kotelnik is a 'decent boxer', but someone can be P4P rated for 'providing entertainment' and beating Kevin Mitchell? You can't big up Maidana on one hand and then not give credit for beating someone who beat Maidana on the other. Who are the names on Gamboa's resume who you think eclipse Kotelnik and Malignaggi?
Cobbler, you're writing bull****. I pointed out that placing Katsidis in top 25 is mostly because of his last 5 fights. Casamayor and Diaz were p4p materials at that time (maybe you started to interest boxing recently, I don't know) and Katsidis gave them war in which he could be the winner with a little bit of luck. Lost is a lost but sometimes the defeated man should get some respect. If you his 3 recent fights which are all wins (Mitchell win at his home town was big) , I see Kats as a worthy to be named p4pounderer. Had you watched Kotelnik-Maidana? I don't think so. Even Germans at the crowd were suprised that Kotelnik got the nod. Why I rate Gamboa over Khan? Gamboa wasn't KO'd cold in 1st round and Khan didn't erased that scar on his record by beating declining and smaller fighters in Barrera, Malignaggi. Win over Kotelnik isn't enough for me. He has a lot more to prove and I think he is capable of doing so. Just stop that hype.
I'm still impressed of Perez's win over Agbeko who beat Darchinyan earlier. I thought that Mares did enough to win though, but it was damn good fight I must admit.