I think you have to rank the fighters according to who you think is better, not only according to official results
I know, judging by the various "robbery polls" that are floating about, that there are a large number of people who thought JMM beat Pac last time out. However, when it comes to P4P lists i can't remember many that had JMM above Pac. I thought JMM won, and was pissed off because I also thought he won the first fight, but in the long run I still have to place him behind Pac because he has officially been given the "L".