Paul Willaims is the best P4P

He definately has potential. He needs a stronger resume to prove it. A past his best Winky, a rematch win over Carlos Quintana he should never of needed in the first place, and a win over Verno Philips doesn't do it for me.

 

I cant understand how some people have him ahead of dawson.

 

I have him at #5. Whether he becomes #1 is only a matter of time.

 

It's not his fault all the ***gots in 147 are ****in scared of fighting him.



He is a WW who can't get anyone to fight him, so he's basically being boycotted out of the division. No Shane. No Cotto. No Floyd. No Margo rematch. Only a fake "calling out" by Clottey.



I don't mind everyone saying he needs more names, but it ain't like the guy doesn't want to fight these guys. tell all these other guys to stop contemplating catchweights and **** trying to chase little Pacman, and fight PW.

 

you might have a case if they both started their careers last year

 

I thik that Pwill and Dawson should rank pretty high on P4P list when you think about the wins that they have. I think that they have better wins then 60% of the top 10. I dont think that Pwill should be no 1, somewhere around 6 or 7 and Dawson should be right next to him at 7 or 8. That is based on WINS.

 

Tommy says he needs a better resume, but I agree with you-it's hard to build up a resume when you have a hard time getting guys in the ring.

 

if mosley cant get a fight against cotto / mayweather / pacman, i think he just might fight williams.

 

i can live with #5 ... for now

 

Mosely ain't goin nowhere near that boy. That ****** came out the closet and admitted openly that he didn't wanna fight PW. And some people have the nerve to talk **** about.... nevermind.

 

I don't understand how Dawson cracks the top 10. He's a very, very good fighter but his resume isn't among the best when you look at it in context. Adamek was weight-drained to an extent and it showed in his performances at 175 prior to the Dawson fight and in that particular fight, Johnson is way past his best, Tarver aswell and he didn't impress me in either Tarver fight not the Glencoffe fight.

If he beats Hopkins, or Calzaghe if he comes back, or moves down to 168 and beats somebody like Bute, Kessler or Froch he will make it, but until then unimpressively beating 40 year old past prime fighters ain't gonna fly with me and ain't gonna get him in my personal top 10.

 

You just need to get everyone else using THAT list.

 

BUMP, plus pw wont be able to fight at 147 again anyway, and if he does try to drop that low again..... :hi:

 

1-Pac
2-JMM
3-Mosley
4-Hopkins
5-Williams
6-Dawson
7-Cotto
8-Vazquez
9-Calderon
10-donaire

I guess 5 is about right

 

:roflatsch