Paul Willaims is the best P4P

I dont think that you could put floyd on the list, he hasnt fought in two years, and there is a chance that he could come back and suck. I dont have a problem with the rest of your list except number 6 fighting 100 fights dont make you p4p, when your not fighting anyone good.

 

I disagree. Winky wasn't shot. The Winky who showed up that night would still give anyone in that division a good fight. It wasn't so much about what Winky did wrong but what Williams did right. Give the man his due.

 

atsch

I give up, if you really believe that then Im done with it.

 

Bull mother ****ing ****

winky hadnt fought in almost 2 years, he sucks now, he will retire soon

p-willie aint done **** but beat an overrated margo.

 

If thats true he should move up in weight. I hope he fights Dziziurik, and if he unifies with a clear win more fans will acknowledge him. To say he's #1 though is insane.

 

You're the ****ing idiot who's trying to make a 8-4 win for Carlos sound like was better than the 1st round KO demolition job that put Carlos on a ****ing milk carton. You sound like a Williams hater with an agenda to push. Give the man his ****ing due.

 

WOW, so you really think beating
WINKY WRIGHT: 2 year layoff feather fisted
VERNO PHILLIPS: Solid but way past his peak(if he ever had one_
ANDY KOLLE: FUTURE HALL OF FAMER
MARGARITO: THE HUMAN PUNCHING BAG
QUINTANA: 1 loss and one KTFO
is better then fighters who have fought
CALZAGHE
JERMAIN TAYLOR
ANDRADE
PASCAL
MIRANDA x2
ARTHUR ABRAHAM
FELIX STURM
I AM DONE WITH YOU, I SWEAR I THOUGHT I HEARD IT ALL!:thumbsup

 

Winky´s almost 40 and hadnt fought in two years,hes clearly past it.

If Williams is top 5 pfp than the current pound for pound list is the weakest of the last 20 years.

 

You know Blade I actually like pwill, but the fanboys are the ones who make you dislike a fighter you actually like. Hopefully pwill vs aa is who aa is going to be fighting on the 27th of June.

 

He doesn't suck. You don't know the difference between a shot fighter and a faded fighter when you see one. Winky could still compete at a top level at 160. Williams was a stylistic nightmare for him a young fighter with a sick work rate.:deal

 

Williams is top 5. He'd beat Cotto or Shane i think thats very obvious. And he could move up and beat most of the guys one or 2 divs north. No other WW could. He's got brutal power, incredible workrate, he's a beast. He's clearly #5


For those who disagree, who you have higher other than JMM, MP, FM or BH?

 

Funny how everyone writes off Williams's win over Winky when half this forum picked Winky to beat Williams. Some even said that Winky was gonna school PWill. But NOW Wright is shot, feather-fisted blah blah blah.

 

Paul Williams isn't even my favorite fighter. I just want to see the man get his due and get the big fights he deserves.

 

Exactly! I also picked Winky mostly because he was one of my favorites.

 

paul williams is the black version of margarito (no gimp c not skillwise).