Andrade IS a top 10 fighter, no doubt. But and this is a big but he would never beat the likes of Calzaghe or Kessler. Bute has not hit his peak yet, and he had all he could handle with a fighter Kessler virtually schooled. I would love to hear your dumb reason on why Calzaghe would be k.o'd by a fighter who has lost the two step up fights he has had? Please tell me. If the fight ever happened Calzaghe 119-109
Joe by possible shutout. he wouldn't fade down the stretch like Bute. 120-108. His stamina is to good.
Calzaghe quits cause he punches his hands off right down to his elbow on Andrades chin. Total mismatch in terms of boxing skill. If it was a "Two men enter one man leave" scenario i would bet on Andrade everytime.
While letting the "styles make fights" argument aside for a second this reads pretty simple: Calzaghe > Kessler >>>>>> Andrade
Calzaghe 8 - 4. I give Andrade 4 because he would be fighting an unmotivated Calzaghe who can put in an iffy performance. I love the fact that people are still walking through Calzaghe's punches/slap's. Calzaghe has no power and cant keep the fighter from pressuring him after he walks through Calzaghe's weak weak shots :rofl:rofl:rofl Seriously Lacy, Kessler and Hopkins all had the opportunity to walk through slappy Calzaghe's weak ass shots and steamroll him heck even Manfredo should be able to take those shots and trouble Calzaghe. Cant remember too much domination and pressure in any of those fights.