Prime Pernell beats Floyd,Pac & JMM anyone disagree?

IMO prime Whitaker ( 89 - 94) gets a decision against all three at either 135 or 147. Floyd would be the hardest but i would still have Pea down for a sd. I dont think pac would be able to land his shots, so without his power it would come down to pure boxing, Pea ud. JMM I believe would have a better chance against Pea than pac as styles make fights but i still see him on the wrong side of a ud.

 

Pernell beats all of them one sided.

 

I have always think that it would be more difficult for floyd to beat jmm than pac because of what you just said, pac wouldnt land his big shots against floyd so thats why, saying this, with your post would you agree with me or what do you think, I know pea and floyd are different but both have very good defenses and I have always think they are kind of similar, would you think jmm would be tougher for floyd than pac?

 

Yes almost everyone will agree.

 

at 143 no. I think jmm will be to small, i dont think naturally he is as big as pac, hence i give pac a better chance. However if all 3 were at 135 which is as high as jmm can be effective against elite fighters then yes i would give jmm more chance

I

 

Pac always has a puncher's chance. Pea has a big edge over JMM as he is slicker, faster AND bigger and had a good punch himself. PBF, I would call it a toss-up.

 

135, he beats them all.

147, Floyd has a live chance.

 

Yeah, I agree, but I think pac gives him the biggest fit of the 3. floyd would be overwhelmed by someone out doing him at what he does best.

 

Why does Floyd has a chance at 147?

Floyd is overated at 147, he's never been tested there with a prime top fighter, and he's not as good as he was in the lower weights.

 

Floyd vs Pea 50/50

Pea vs Pac 65/35

Pea vs JMM 80/20

 

Pea was coked up half the time at 147 and clearly past prime.

I love the guy to death, but I think a prime Mayweather has a shot at welter.

 

Pea was great..An old shot pea beat a prime Oscar and had Tito running and holding at the end of their fight.

I think that Pea beats them all, not as easy as some seem to think...These guys are too great fighters, a different era but still great.

 

Pernell>All of the above

 

I don't. In a way Pernell is similar to Pacman now only Pernell is better defensively and Pacman punches harder. Very similar fighters. Speedwise.

 

what he said...