So who's higher in your P4P, JoeCal or JMM?

chliJs · Nov 4, 2007

brooklyn1550 said:

Joe Calzaghe is higher - by two places (2 to Marquez's 4)

Calzaghe, in the past year and a half, has unified the WBC, WBA, WBO, and IBF titles and has increased his title defense number to 21. I think his win over an undefeated world champion Jeff Lacy is more impressive than Marquez's recent win over Rocky Juarez. And despite Marco Antonio Barrera being an ATG, I think Calzaghe beat Mikkel Kessler in a more decisive fashion. While Barrera at his best was a better fighter than Kessler, I think Barrera of 2007 was about the same level of Kessler or slightly under.

Plus, Calzaghe is 44-0 while Marquez has lost to Chris John recently.
Click to expand...

i fully agree with everything but the last sentence.

the chris john fight wasn't just controversial, it was a clear robbery. in the end it doesn't matter, but still it should not just be ignored and pretended like he really lost the fight. i'm no big supporter of marquez, just like you i rank him beneath calzaghe, i think pacquiao won the fight and i thought it was pure entertainment when barrera fought dirty against him... but it was a robbery and it's nothing you can use against him.

McGrain · Nov 4, 2007

I think that Joe has slipped in ahead of JMM for me, though I'm not 100% yet. I think Joe is #3, I think JMM is #4...

nighthunter · Nov 5, 2007

CAZA for sure because of his accomplishment

Log in or Sign up

So who's higher in your P4P, JoeCal or JMM?

chliJs Active Member Full Member

McGrain Diamond Dog Staff Member

nighthunter Active Member Full Member