His best win was Ramirez if you want to say becoming undisputed in a weak 140 is more accomplished than what Spence accomplished be my guest. Historically it won't be and Spence will be seen as the greater fighter.
And those wins have all aged badly/terribly Broner is a four-weight champion too and he also has a trash resume Taylor is a one-weight champ with a better resume than four-weight champ Broner Rolly is another PBC/Showtime hype job. The only reason he became a champ is because of the brazen corruption of Premier Boxing Criminals. Rolly lost to Twink, lost to Cruz, clearly lost to Jackson Martinez, and was well on his way to losing to 40 y/o cherry pick Barroso too until that corrupt snake Tony Weeks literally waved the fight off over nothing which in case you forgot is how Rolly became a champ. Rolly is not a top player How did he waltz into an immediate title shot at 140 after losing his previous fight via KO at 135? Ryan is a hype job whose only real claim to fame is IG and beating the crap out Haney who fell apart the first time he fought someone who could punch he didn't weigh 2-4 weight classes more than and didn't reside in a care home Haney just ran like a thief in the night from 1-12 vs a completely washed JCR whose power he was absolutely petrified of Clenelo is shot to bits, hasn't stopped anyone since the end of 2021 despite the fact he's been cherrypicking binmen with the exception of Bivol. And This content is protected
Canelos already shot to bits after beating 3 contenders?? Lol weren't people saying Canelo was going to manhandle and destroy "weightbully crapford"
Taylor might not have the marquee name on his resume but he blitzed through a division in a ridiculously short time and became undisputed in 18 fights. Faced undefeated fighter after undefeated fighter, ducked nobody, and all without a major promoter too for most of it. Leaving the UK’s best trainer in McGuigan didn’t help and he lost motivation once becoming undisputed. Yes he’s not been great recently and burnt out quickly but he’s had an amazing career and is one of the UK’s best.
Not me because I've been telling everyone for years how big Crawford is I told everyone before he fought Madrimov that not only wasn't it the size mismatch everyone naively believed it was going to be but that Crawford would at worst weigh the same as Madrimov or even weigh more and once again, for the millionth time, Serge was proven 100% correct Berlangy, Mung, and Scull are binmen
You saying Spence is "light years" better is just laughable you may think he is better but he is not levels above him that is just plain hating on Taylor. Prime Prograis and Ramirez is better than any win on Spence's resume. Name one A+ win Spence has?
I never said Taylor had any A+ wins I said his wins over undefeated Prograis and Ramirez are better than any win Spence has. Brook was coming off having his orbital bone broken by GGG and moving back down to 147 he was compromised. Porter was already shopworn having lost to Brook and Thurman and going life and death with Ugas and Garcia. Yes they are bigger names but it is all about context. The only A+ fighter Spence fought was Crawford and he absolutely mopped the floor with Spence in embarrassing fashion.
People keep trying to downplay becoming undisputed in 18 fights Which is 3 fights before Spence even won a world title and 10 before he became undisputed And 5 fights before Crawford even won a world title and 14 before he became undisputed And as I said earlier, Spence forged a career cleaning out 147 of its 140 pounders and 135 Mikey, barely facing any legit punchers, and only facing two career 147 pounder champions in his entire career and only defending against one throughout his six year reign. He's being gassed up for beating a damaged goods Brook who was coming off a bad beating, a stoppage loss, coming back down from 160 after bulking up to fight up there, and a terrible eye injury and gruesome surgery to repair it when Brook suffered the exact same injury against him which was caused by a head clash in round 8 which completely changed the complexion of the fight Taylor is being crucified for beating a 26-0 JCR, 24-0 Rougarou, 29-1 Postol, 19-0 Baranchyk, 26-0 Catterall (very controversial), 22-0 Martin,16-0 Khongsong, 15-0 Ohara, 39-5 Vazquez in just 19 fights, all of whom bar Vazquez are career 140 pounders and many are big punchers but Spence is being glorified for cleaning out 147 of its 140 pounders, 135 Mikey, and generally facing featherfists and average punchers at best, and beating damaged goods Brook and Porter but who has Brook beaten really apart from Porter? Go look at his resume And Porter is another guy who barely fought any legit punchers his size, beat up 140-135 pounders Paulie, Broner, Danny, Ugas, Alexander, Julio Diaz and he lost to almost all the top 147 pounders he fought albeit competitively
I think a prime Taylor was very good not great. I was a big fan but he came along at just the right time. The top contenders at the weight were good, entertaining fighters. He made the most of his window of opportunity.
Thing is Spence avoided any dangerous offensive fighters. The biggest puncher he beat was a past it Danny Garcia. At least Baranchyk and Prograis were explosive hitters.