+ The Super Middleweight Top 10 Thread +

maybe ive only 40 posts but im no noob i was banned a long time ago from this website....i know my boxing!:canada

 

Agreed -- I been saying this forever, but Froch's low left makes him target practice for Pavlik's right hand, and Taylor is WAAAAY to fast for Froch. Kessler is just to skilled. Froch is more at a Zuniga or Miranda level than a top 5 guy. I'm not saying there is no chance of him changing his status, but if he can, he needs to prove it instead of just repeatedly damanding attention via his mouth.

 

Kessler
Bute
Andrade
Taylor
Bika
Inkin
Froch
Mundine
Balzsay
Pascal

 

In reality Inkin has done nothing but "beat" Zuniga, when many who have seen the fight call it a robbery....So thats it, a robbery against a top journeyman and you rate him above Bika, and Andrade? That is bull**** my friend....I can understand Froch but in no goddamn way is Inkin better than Andrade or Bika....Both would murder him:fire

 

There ya go thread over.

 

Andrade faced Kessler and Bute. He's the guy who faced the best opposition. Kessler faced Calzaghe, Andrade, Mundine, Bute faced Andrade, Bika and Berrio, Froch faced Reid when Reid was not himself anymore. Taylor has a super resume at MW. So, Pacal, Froch, Green, Ward, Dirrell, Inkin, Balsay have to prove themselves. They all may be very good. We just don't know exactly.

 

1 froch
2 kessler
3 taylor
4 bute
5 inkin
6 pascal
7 lacy
8 bika
9 manfredo
10 mundine

 

1. Mikkel Kessler
2. Lucian Bute
3. Carl Froch
4. Jermain Taylor
5. Librado Andrade
6. Denis Inkin

I don't really feel like going any further either, you could debate any number of guys beyond that and not have a convincing argument for ranking one above the other. Maybe Bika deserves the next slot.

 

:rofl :rofl :rofl :rofl :rofl :rofl

 

wow super middle is stacked right now!!! lots of quality fights to be made, I hope a clear unified champ emerges soon.

 

Terrible.

 

True Andrade faced Bute and Kessler and if it was not of Bute going crazy by slugging it out in the 12,he would have won ONE round in these 2 fights ....im pretty damn sure inkin would have won more than ONE round only in the kessler fight...so you say Andrade is better than Inkin based on the fact he was outboxed easily all night long by Kessler and almost the same by Bute(exception of the 5 and 12 rounds,only rounds Andrade won)Andrade is a tough tough man with big courage but anyone who can take his punch and just box a little bit can outbox him rather easily...and i think Inkin has the technical advantages over Andrade...only question is his chin...:huh

 

1 frochatsch :rasta :smoke :nut :rofl
2 kessler
3 taylor
4 bute
5 inkin
6 pascalatsch
7 lacyatsch
8 bika
9 manfredoatsch
10 mundine[/quote]

 

Plus a shot(past his prime) Julio Cesar Vasquez