These group of fighters vs Rocky Marciano.

I can draw a conclusion on all five of the proposed outcomes in about five seconds

 

I just wanna say, Marciano was never beaten with a pillow. That’s just ridiculous.

This analogy also ignores the plateauing effect re both power and resistance with increased size and when approaching and exceeding the 200 lb or so threshold.

 

Did Marciano murder your Grandma or something?

 

Hi Buddy.
So my response would go something like this.
You premise is that smaller boxers have given Marciano trouble and are capable of beating him, the only small flaw in your case is both Lowry and Moore were not the " smaller " opponent when they fought Rocky !! both were taller, and Lowry's weight was 180, and Moore's was 188, and Marciano's weight was 185 or their about, so he wasn't given trouble by a middleweight ( Lowry ) or a 160 pounder ( Moore ) they were HW or HWs of that era, had either weighed 160/170 your point would stand, as it is, your point is diluted .
Just to add some context to the Lowry fight, Marciano was having his 21st fight ( and sort of still learning ) as opposed to Lowry who had around 120 fights by that time, also you say Hearns beat Miller who was " bigger and more skilled " than Marciano, I am sure Tommy could beat dozens of fighters with that criteria, but that doesn't presuppose he would have beaten Marciano.
By way of balance, I share your view that Rocky would have struggled with the truly big HWs that you named, and could have lost against all 6 , hope you take my reply in good humour, and its just my point of view, that's all. stay safe buddy.

 

Mike, all I can say is, you’re a better man than I Gunga Din.

I hope to achieve your level of class in the face of less than classy responses.

Somehow, I think the horse has bolted on that possibility for me. LOL.

We should all aspire to Mike Cannon’s Canon for which you should be Canonised.

We already have a self appointed Holy Man - @Saintpat - but he isn’t altogether that holy, more brimstone and fire actually (kidding, Mr Saint).

So, stay safe yourself buddy, always a pleasure to read.

 

I know, right? Marciano = The Rocky Horror Picture Show.

 

Many thanks matey, much appreciated, you are a top poster yourself, always interested in your opinions and foresight. chat soon buddy.

 

Ok, thanks for the response, I am being totally honest when I say, your points and predictions leave me somewhat baffled, as for you saying because Pac ko Hatton then he would clearly do same to Marciano has left me almost speechless, and if I may be so bold, going forward try not to assume that you know how a poster thinks, and also who he favours, that's not possible my friend , for the record I am not a Marciano fan-boy, I do admire and respect his achievement's as a undefeated champion , as I would with any fighter that compiles a record like Marciano's, and lastly, using a rather childish remark such as " little kid " does you a disservice, and only alienates you on this forum, as always feel free to voice your thoughts and opinions, but try to keep your response's mature and civilised , that done they will carry more weight.
This is my last word on our posts, wish you well for the future, and look forward to many more posts between us on other topics. stay safe.

 

Yes, that group of fighters would probably beat Marciano. He was only one man.