Toney would kick his ass. Speed and power, ok. No defense and a dodgy chin against Toney is not very good.
Toney wins this one for me. Against an old and diminished Holyfield who was still dangerous he just put a systematic beatdown on the guy and looked sharp as hell in doing so. At heavyweight that's the best I think Toney has ever been and Haye at this stage isn't tested enough at heavyweight.
Toney was in good shape for the Holyfield fight, I'll say Toney wins by TKO rds 7 to 10. Same outcome if they fought at CW. Hayes best weapon is his punching power, but that won't give Toney problems, because Haye won't land much on the defensive master that Toney is. And even if Haye should land a good punch, Toneys iron chin will withstand it. Haye is tailormade for Toney, because he fights aggressive and leaves himself wide open after he throws his punches, plus he has a shaky chin. Toney will counterpunch him silly, bust him up and then finish him later in the fight.
If Haye with his speed lands a lot of big shots Toney could be in trouble Also Toney is fat so Haye would just pound the body
Toney wins, not even close. Toney weighed in less than 220 for the Holyfield fight, he was in shape. This Toney beats Haye. Haye might win now.
Well, if the fight was now maybe Haye could outwork an old, out of shape and fat Toney. But never an in-shape Toney like the version that fought Holyfield, or Jirov, that's the version of Toney we are talking about. He wasn't fat then. For every punch Haye throws (and misses), he'd eat a couple countershots. C'mon, Toney was near his very best in those fights, he may not be now, but to say that Haye would beat the Toney that fought Holyfield... nothing against Haye, he's a good fighter, the best CW right now and he'll probably do well at HW, but to say that he beats these ATGs... he is way overrated here... Plus, Toney would completely own Haye when it comes to trash-talking. Toney is one of the funniest and wittiest talkers in boxing, while Haye just acts tough and gangsta. To me it seems that Haye wants to copy Zab Judah when he talks trash, and he doesn't even do it very good... he can't even embarass Klitschko with his talking...
I agree Toney is nothing but a fat ass Middleweight with a good chin. That is all he ever was? Its only the shitty competition that makes him look a 1000X better than he really is (as a heavyweight). Hayle by one sided UD, or KO if he can land the right hand cleanly.
that version of Toney woulda schooled Haye and stopped him. Today Toney is totallly done and would drop a decision. Nobody is knocking him out though.