fair enough, but I do think the quillin win was significant. take that out and yeah you're pretty close
When PBF went inactive he was P4P #1 he has never lost so now that he's back he goes back to #1 where he belongs. Kinda like when he retired the 1st time. I never once ranked Pac #1 P4P because he didn't earn it and PBF didn't lose.
I just don't think Thurman is that good. He arguably lost to Porter and I think PBF Brook and Spence beat him.
When was the last relevant fight Rigo was in? His competition has been awful. Also, Canelo the majority of his 'big' fights have been at catchweights which tells us he isn't a P4P fighter or he would have fought at the Divisional limit.
Kovalev has a chance to move up this Saturday if he beats Ward. Rigo is still undefeated and has been basically frozen out of the sport at no fault of his own.
Really good. I wouldn't have AJ top 10, but that's just a quibble. You'll be the most brilliant guy here if Canelo beats GGG.
Pretty good list most of those guys are lineal champs a requirement to be considered p4p in my opinion. But my man TBE is retired? and fighting exhibitions dont count.
ROFLMAO You've totally lost it Cheatweather #1 ??? You really ought to remove that altar to Mayweather you worship to Je's been EXPOSED as a CHEAT !!!!
Good thread. My main differences would be that I'd have GGG in and AJ out. AJ is the best heavyweight, but he needs to beat at least one of the other top fighters who is not 40 to make it certain. I also think he benefits from the fact that he is bigger than most of the division, which is something I personally take into account in p4p lists.
40 y/o Floyd ain't anywhere near my top 10, I think Kovalev beat Ward so have them in different positions and can't possibly justify having the haircut in there!
Good list besides mayweather returning to number 1. Not worthy a p4p rating until he fights someone world level which I'm guessing he won't so I don't think he deserves a mention atm