What division is the deepest?

main one's for me are, in no specific order:

Bantamweight
Featherweight
Lightweight
Light Welter
Super Middleweight

 

He seems like a good fighter and just missed making the top 10, partly cause of his spotty record and with Holts out of the ring problems may have affected him. One more quality win and hes in. Maybe you can make a case for him over Peterson but not Diaz,at least not yet.

 

heavyweight. knee deep in tomato cans.

 

Light Welter for depth

Feather for quality (John, Lopez, Gamboa, Cabellero, Marquez, Vasquez etc)

 

118, 168, and 140

 

Featherweight

 

No, according to me. When I think someone has better arguments I rethink the standing of the fighter we are discussing. I stand firm when I think my arguments are right. For example I rank Schmeling and Patterson in the Top15 at hw, Ali not in the Top10, well only borderline Top15 and so on. I´m still open minded.

You on the other hand are stubborn and biased. :yep

 

wheres is the depth at light wetler???

 

I'm a fan of 154lbs.

 

I may be reading you wrong but did you just say you don't rank Ali in your HW top 10?

 

Is this your 'heavyweight champions' theory thing? It's ****ing nonsense either way, but just asking.

 

Deepest? Featherweight.

Yuri Gamboa
Chris John
Juanma Lopez
Celestino Caballero
Orlando Salido
Cristobal Cruz
Elio Rojas
Jhonny Gonzalez
Daniel Ponce de Leon
Israel Vazquez
Rafael Marquez
Bernabe Concepcion
Steven Luevano
Fernando Beltran
Mikey Garcia
Rocky Juarez
Oleg Yefimovych
Juan Carlos Burgos
Ryol Li Lee
Daud Yordan
Plus about 15 or so more guys who are solid but wouldn't beat the top guys, like Escobedo, Bautista, Lindsay, Lock, Dib, Cordoba, Barros, etc.


There isn't another weight class out there where you can go 20 names deep to find legitimate contenders.

 

Bantamweight, Jr Welterweight, Supermiddle. Although it must be mentioned that Welterweight would make the cut if Floyd and Manny weren't obliterating everyone they faced. Welter's still up there, just not quite as high as it was since Manny took out Cotto and, for all intents and purposes, it looks like Floyd finished Mosley. Feather and Welter would probably round out my top 5.

 

Nah, p4p.