What's your top 10 P4P all time?

Absolutely no idea!

 

Wait, do you mean Willie Meehan or Kali Meehan?

It's a great list BTW

 

for Felix Savon and Lazlo Papp!

 

I'd just like to post this guys list once more. Rhas Al Guhl
1. Roy Jones Jr.
2. Teofilo Stevenson
3. Ricardo Lopez
4. Edward Henry Greb
5. Henry Armstrong
6. Laszlo Papp
7. Floyd Mayweather
8. Felix Savon
9. Ray Robinson
10. Thomas Hearns
11. Rocky Marciano
12. Julio Cesar Chavez
13. Joe Louis
14. Carlos Monzon
15. Archie Moore
16. Benny Leonard
17. Gene Tunney
18. Marvin Hagler
19. Pernell Whitaker
20. Jack Briton

 

You say that like its normal to have Tommy Hearns top 10

 

Where's Ali

 

Yeah, coz that's the problem

 

No particular order
Pep
Moore
SRR
Ali
Louis
Charles
Mayweather (that’s right haters lol)
Duran
Armstrong
RJJ (glad I’m not the only one)
I will say I didn’t forget about Greb and Langford it’s more their poor era that gets me to vote otherwise. But the amount of fights they had is commendable and records thag will never be broken

 

1. Sugar Ray Robinson
2. Joe Louis
3. Benny Leonard
4. Henry Armstrong
5. Muhammad Ali
6. Willie Pep
7. Ezzard Charles
8. Roberto Duran
9. Sam Langford
10. Emile Griffith

 

Interesting choice, how come mate?

 

Have not redone one like I mean to as I keep putting it off.

but at last note:

1 SRR
2 Greb
3 Armstrong
4 Langford
5 Charles
6 Benny Leonard
7 Fitzsimmons
8 Gans
9 Louis
10 Ali

 

He was a great Welterweight in a tough era. The level of his comp was top shelf. He also moved up and won the Middleweight Crown. Griffith had longevity. He even gave the great Monzon a brutal fight when Emile was way past it. He fought everyone.
A great all around fighter. He could do everything. Its criminal how overlooked he is.

 

I like the inclusion of Wilde personally (FMJ as well although I have not rated him as of yet...I do feel he is top 20-25 at the worst)...I kind of (Still fleshing it out and have not worked on it recently) have him (meaning Wilde) around 11/12 with Duran.

I know his record is incomplete but I also know you did some digging into him a little deeper a while back. I have seen him top 10 before but not often anymore...anything you can add to justify a top 10 would be appreciated. Not criticizing just genuinely curious and interested to learn.

 

Greb
Robinson
Duran
Fitz
Langford
Pep
Charles
Louis
Armstrong
Walker