Where does Wilder fit as a H2H HW?

Ok, so you just started the thread for kicks and giggles. I'll play along. As of right now, he fits in somewhere between Herbie Hide and Bruce Seldon on the HW ATG list.

 

Loses to these guys:
Ali
Tyson
Wlad
Vitali
Lewis
Holmes (upset possible)
Louis (upset possible)
Liston (upset possible)

IDK:
Joshua
Holyfield
Foreman
Blond Ortiz

Probably beats:
Sanders
Witherspoon
M Spinks
Dempsey
Tunney
Povetkin
Frazier
Bowe
Roy Jones
Haye
Ibeabuchi

Lights go out:
Patterson
Marciano
Norton
Page
Dokes
Douglas
Moorer

...approaching top 10 h2h

 

Hes top 20 only bc he can win as easily lose,hes going to be one of those guys that you either have him losing bad to holmes or catching Holmes...etc....

A head to head with this guy is like putting him maybe over OLd late 90's foreman so in that equation hes a threat. Should he somehow defeat fury and more importantly Joshua it then changes the spectrum.

but reality is he can be anywhere from Ruddock to Cooney and in between where the wind blows bc hes got by a big puncher with no speed and smaller guys with less power. his resume is thin ,his last fight was his first power puncher and that doesn't tell us much except maybe he could hurt old foreman ,but Breazeale never landed clean he just wobbled him back with the first punch landed and then..........?

But 1990's Foreman shouldn't be on anyone's top 10 H2H. I could probably list 20 guys who defeats him including some now.

The problem here is how do you do fantasy match ups with this guy who needs a knock out ? MOST top guys one can see them out boxing guys at leas t,how many fights will Wilder win LEGIT without a K.O ? Remains to be seen.

 

Wilder fits as being able to late KO a 40something with no world title pedigree, as his best achievement.

The H2H ability of a rising contender, in other worlds. Which is a shame seeing as hes a adult in his mid 30s.

 

Terrible evaluation, disgusting in fact

 

I suspect it always will be "too early to tell".

 

Fact of the matter is that his power means the slimmest chance he can ever have in any fight is a puncher's chance.

 

Is there something that upset you about my list?

 

I honestly don't know where to start

 

Apart from maybe Holyfield being left off the first category and Marciano in the last category, there’s nothing too crazy.

 

But beating Sam Peter and povetkin does?