Which 'bad' decision in the history of boxing bothers you most?

Delahoya Trinidad

Chavez Whitaker

Barrera Marquez

 

Recently,

JMM agains Pacquiao - third fight
Abril vs Rios - Just because it was so obvious they were going to do it too him even though Rios won at most two rounds.

 

Tyson Douglas poor counting

 

Recently....mayweather vs maidana

He got cheated of his gloves and his win.

 

:rofl:good

 

chavez v whitaker draw for me

 

because most people including myself only gave pac 1 more round then moretti ?

117-111. ? go check the list of ringside and reputable scorecards

 

Maidana did deserve a draw, imo he won 5, I gave Floyd 5, the other two were close so I wasn't averse to a one round win either way but a draw was therefore the fairest result.

Marquez won that third fight, his ****ing face after the decision's are announced always makes me sad lol.

Martinez beat Williams in 1. You're most likely better off avoiding the rematch if you get a disputed decision because look at this

Martinez KO Williams
Marquez KO Pacquiao
Tarver KO Jones

 

I realize I'm responding to a troll in CJ, but the draw scorecard in Mayweather-Canelo was definitely worse.

118-110 for Floyd over Pacquiao....116-112 for Floyd is a popular and fair scorecard. That's 2 rounds off, going from 10-2 to 8-4.

114-114 in Mayweather-Canelo...If you're two rounds off in that one, going from 6-6 to 8-4, that's 116-112 Mayweather. That's still generous to the Ginger.

 

The other 2 judges were more realistic 116-112. I scored it 115-113 to Mayweather & that was being generous to him. He did nothing but run , hold & pull on Pac's right arm. That no one knew was seriously hurt according to NSAC ROFL I laugh there but it wasn't funny to see a fighter get sabotaged the way Pacquaio was. For having an injured opponent fighting in pain Mayweather's performance was cowardly. Even his own father basically called Floyd a coward.
I still say a 100% fit Pac , fighting anywhere BUT Vegas , kicks Floyd's a$$:hi:

 

Me a troll ROFL I'm an old time boxing fan who likes to see a fair fight with no bias or corruption on EITHER side.
With Mayweather & NSAC/Vegas this never happens. Floyd's opponents NEVER get an even break. The deck is always heavily stacked in Floyd's favour. What with which gloves they can use,& other ludicrous demands & stipulations
I was dead serious before the Floyd-Pac fight when I said " If its a level straight down the middle fight & Floyd LEGITIMATELY wins I'd be the first to congratulate him & say he was the better man on the night. In fact I did congratulate him BEFORE I heard how Pacquaio had been sabotaged by the NSAC on fight night & before I saw a tape of the fight. I took back my congratulations immediately.
In fact I still think a 100% fit Pac, fighting on a level playing field anywhere BUT Vegas & the corruption, still Kicks Mayweather's a$$ But we all know Mayweather hasn't the cojones to do that

 

Haven't read all of the thread so may have been said, but maybe Tony Weeks calling off the fight instead of giving Taylor the opportunity to finish the fight with Chavez. Hindsight is a wondeful thing, and I'm sure he acted with the best of intent, but looking back it is a great shame.

 

Hagler vs Leonard

 

Whitaker vs Rivera 1