Who beat Valuev more convincingly in your opinion??

I thought Holyfield clearly won in what was an extrememly uneventuful "fight".
I thought Chagaev was really close, in what was also a rather dull affair.

 

Holyfield did nothing in that fight. The biggest damage holydid was with his Head banging..

 

Lyakovich beat him too

 

agreed. valuev fights are difficult to score due to boredom as well.

 

I thought both clearly won equally yet I might give a slight big towards holyfield for landing more clean shots, but both were real close in my book.

 

I don't think Holyfield beat him anywhere near as clearly as some people are making out. It's really easy to score against someone who you dislike as a boxer and bores you to death, especially when he is fighting a living legend going for the record for the oldest HW champion ever.

I don't think I've ever seen such a boring fight, but a draw would have been reasonable or a slight edge for Holyfield, all evander did was run all night.

Chagaev, despite looking terrible last night, actually looked slick against Valuev! lol, I'm not sure if it is a bit of revisionism given his performance last night, but Chagaev clearly beat Valuev, much more so than Holyfield.

I can't remember the Donald fight.

 

Evander beat him by nine or ten rounds.

 

The most convincing win was the hunter than abducted him from the woods, shaved him and taught him to talk...ish.