Vasyl Lomachenko 48 vote(s) 66.7% Terence Crawford 6 vote(s) 8.3% Canelo Alvarez 1 vote(s) 1.4% Keith Thurman 0 vote(s) 0.0% Gennady Golovkin 15 vote(s) 20.8% Mikey Garcia 1 vote(s) 1.4% Naoya Inoue 0 vote(s) 0.0% Sergey Kovalev 0 vote(s) 0.0% Errol Spence Jr 0 vote(s) 0.0% Someone not in the poll, post his name 1 vote(s) 1.4% http://4.bp.blogspot.com/-3PZhBqkbF.../iIiTVLroxNA/s1600/patrick-bateman-upvote.jpg
Talentwise it's Lomachenko or Crawford. In my opinion neither guy has the resume to make the claim yet. Out of Loma's six best opponents, two weren't 130 pounders. He lost to the guy with the least amount of talent of the six, and three of them quit without giving an honest effort to try and win. Not great for building up a pound for pound claim. Crawford hasn't faced any elite opposition, so he ain't number one either. Honestly it's wide open right now between the two. Lomachenko beats Russell Jr. again, or the winner of Garcia vs Easter, and he has it, I don't expect either of those guys to quit. Crawford won't be able to make the claim until he fights a Haymon fighter. Beating Horn, or Pac won't move him up at this point. Nobody else on the list deserves consideration for the top spot.
Im suprised that only myself has picked mikey. A three weight world champion whos dipped his toe into the next division and beat one of the top guys at 140. Whilst loma is impressive you seem to of all gone a bit fanboys since his win on sat. Even loma said it was nothing impressive to beat rigo who at 37 yrs was 2 div down in weight. Crawford cleaned out the 140ers, ye sure he did, and he needs big respect for doing that. but crawford whilst been a good fighter always held an advantage at 140, he was massive for the weight. Lets see how he does at 147 without the size advantage. He aint no1 p4p atm, not imo. Whats wrong with mikey guys?
Both Loma and Bud would smash the hell out of Broner, it would be beautiful to watch as well. Who has Garcia tested himself against? Broner? Broner's not a better name than either Postol or GR JR.
Bud would yes i agree. Broners not a better name than Postol? I beg to differ on that. Mikeys got Salido on his list. Loma lost to Salido
Mikey is a bigger guy than Loma with better power, at a higher weight. He was supposed to beat Salido. I have Garcia at number 7 at the moment, till he steps up his level of competition, he's no claim to P4P number 1. Like guys like Porter have beaten Broner, MM did. Were they top ten P4P fighters? Nope.
Mikey beat salido when they were both fighting in the same division. i hear what your saying about broner but broner aint no real force at 147. At 140 thats his best division now, although the bigger paydays were at 147. Broner at 140 is a hard fight. At 147 not so hard. Im just suprised that no one picked mikey. 3 weight world champ. If loma could beat mikey then he would be no1.
I hope you people know that there is actually NO such thing really? It's a concept based on fantasy scenarios. Fun but fiction. I love ****ing with people who put real stock into it..