Who ranks the highest in terms of p4p ability (not resume) in their prime?

Loma...

 

Pac

 

Pac for sure.

 

Pac is clear.

 

Loma. skill is superior to any other boxer on the list and overall is very impressive. I don't see any fighter of his size, beating him.

 

Don't know its not Pac. In fact, its prolly like this:

Pac


Loma

Ward

Ward was a good SMW and all and has a legitimate call for GOAT SMW but he lost Kovalev 1 and was not impressive in a P4P sense.

Loma and Pac both moved lots of weight classes and won big even when they were smaller, especially Manny.

 

I would actually say Loma is the answer to your question -

- but Pac is far and above the greater fighter out of them and tied it all together better.

 

PAC by a mile.

From the second to the third JMM fight he was a phenom.

 

Pac, and Loma. Ward lost to Kovalev the first time, and the second time it was a boxing match with plenty of fouls. Ward was not impressive at all.

 

Listen, the whole reason Ward rematched Kovalev is because of how controversial the outcome was. The fans literally booed Andre during his "victory speech". Any website or video that reviews fights usually includes that 1st fight as an example of a fight that had an incorrect outcome...it was worse than GGG Canelo 1 even but not as bad as Lara Williams.

I know youre fine w the official outcome cause you have an apparent bias in favor of black fighters which is evidenced by your post history bigging up Floyd, Tank, Spence (formerly), and Deontay and your handle is literally "ellerbe". That is perfectly fine because its your opinion, but rational fans w less prejudice saw Kovalev beat Ward:

https://www.boxingforum24.com/threa...1-2-the-most-egregious-robberies-ever.710876/

https://www.boxingforum24.com/threads/worse-robbery-kovalev-vs-ward-1-or-lomachenko-vs-haney.706696/

https://www.boxingforum24.com/threa...d-vs-kovalev-1-or-haney-vs-lomachenko.704050/

https://www.boxingforum24.com/threads/kovalev-vs-ward-i-is-5-years-old-today.677645/

https://www.boxingforum24.com/threads/i-cant-watch-ward-kovalev-i-because-the-decision.634858/

https://www.boxingforum24.com/threa...-gone-either-way-discussing-aj-ruiz-2.635469/

https://www.boxingforum24.com/threa...golovkin-beat-canelo-fury-beat-wilder.627094/

https://www.boxingforum24.com/threads/ward-still-lost-to-kovalev-the-first-fight.612678/

https://www.boxingforum24.com/threa...o-you-rank-them-in-order-of-closeness.593983/

https://www.boxingforum24.com/threads/your-score-for-ward-vs-kovalev-1.591692/

And non bf24 content:

https://eyeonthering.com/boxing/pound-pound-sergey-kovalev-vs-andre-ward-i

This content is protected

26 for Kovalev, 9 for Ward, 3 draw

And thank you for correcting me about Loma. I was wrong...for some reason I thought it was 3-4 classes. Guess he's on par or even below Ward in that case

 

Pacquiao easily.

 

Pacquiao, not even close