Who's #1 P4P after May>

Honestly, Mayweather could've beat his Uncle Roger coming out of retirement and they would've made him number 2 to hype a fight with Pac.

My point in that particular discussion wasn't P4P though, it was championships, and i don't see y Pac's top WW wen he won a title that was vacant before Cotto "won" it and den Pac won it not at WW but a catchweight. Mosley beat a real WW(a cheater at that) to win his title and he's being considered number 2 or 3 as a WW when he has a belt(which eliminates Floyd as top WW in my opinion) and fought at 147 not a catchweight.

 

Mosley is!!! Even if you use your lil ABC theory, lets compare the results of those matches. Mosley-Cotto a none spectualar desicion, Cotto-Margo questionable TKO, Mosley-Margo clear TKO. Mosley is the man at WW because he won the title at WW which Pac didn't.

And you can say the catchweight had nothing to do with it, when it does. Even if it was closer to Miguels weight you have to realize Cotto had to dehydrate and diet to lose that weight more den he would to make 147. Pac was eating just fine and lifting weights gaining muscle. There's an energy advantage in Pac's favor, and Cotto didn't blame it but maybe him going up to 154 says something.

 

I know thanks for restating what you put in bold moron.
and yea i saw the fight more den once actually.
but i thank you for re-enforcing my point.

 

In my opinion he had to fight both the loser and the winner of SSM-FMJ. I mean he'll probably keep his spot honestly(I don't think he should.) Also I know the choices are messed up. They were bias to see how many *******s and floydfags would stuff the ballot but not support their reasoning with a comment. I voted Mosley because beating Mayweather is just gonna out shine Pac's Win, Mayweather beating Mosley will too but not as much as it being vice versa. Pac will probably keep his spot though, just because the Ring Magazine will want the winner of SSM-FMJ to beat him for the #1 spot.

 

You're right clearly stating Hatton is a JWW was wrong. I'm so dumb for not knowing that that's how Pac got the JWW title. I totally shouldn't have said that. Eventhough my entire point was Pac's a JWW not a WW

 

When did Mosley fight Hatton? Thats right...NEVER!! You're so busy hating on Floyd(who's name wasn't even mention in the quote you used) that you can't even pay attention to what I said multiple times in that quote. MOSLEY IS THE TOP WW, not P4P, I know this!!

Manny is the top P4P, but IMO he is not the #1 WW!!!(Top JWW IMO) Idk if you knew this, but there's a big difference between being the top P4P and the top WW and Manny is(for now atleast) top P4P but he isn't top WW in my eyes.

 

If Manny is tied with Mosley even if Manny has the advantage. Does Mosley become number 1 soley if he beats Floyd again and Manny beats Berto? (Williams is a whole different story to tell.)