Who's #1 P4P after May>

how awesome would mosely vs. pac be?

that would be great. would love to see mosely beat mayweather and then fight pac. is there anyone who really thinks pac vs. mayweather would be more fun/exciting???

 

It really depends on the performances of each man. If Shane dominates Floyd or Vice versa....Floyd or Shane should be on top....if they both struggle and Manny dominates...he should be on top. If Manny Struggles against Josh and still wins of course Floyd or Shane who dominated would be viewed as the top fighter at WW. The thing about Manny is the fact that he's been moving up through the weight classes and dominating so his P4P status stronger b/c of this....but at the end of May, all 3 of these guys are P4P worthy...who ever dominates and exceeds expectations will be the #1 guy.

 

does 1 pound really makes difference??the point is cotto already mosley so cotto is the man to beat in the division when margarito got caught with the handwraps..so pac remains at the top spot until they beat him

 

Mayweather. If he beats Mosley he's beaten the No.2 and No.3 fighters (when he came back). And by the rationale of "beat the man to be the man" Pacquiao shouldn't even be top 5 at WW (most have him as 1/2), unless its "beat the top 5 man at a catchweight and a finished boxer to be the man"

 

Pac stays No1 imo.

Pac was No1 when he beat Cotto, a far better win than JMM at weight, that pushed Pac further ahead.

If PBF beats SSM and if Pac beats Clottey Mayweather catches up again, but is still behind.

 

Josh gonna whoop on pac n than floyd mosley be for the #1 spot!

 

MOSLEY DESTROYED MARGARITO WHO HAD COTTO COWERING IN THE CORNER ON ONE KNEE!!! IT'S A FACT!!! IT HAPPENED!!!1!

On a serious note it's hard to say as Mayweather was out for so long, he beat JMM and went straight in at P4P#2 so if he beats Mosley who is currently P4P#3 then I think there's a good chance he gets the top spot back.

 

Though Ring magazine will see it differently no doubt.

 

Pac will be #1 still, Mosley will be #2.

 

Very good post. Nice seeing someone making some sense in this thread.

 

The winner of Mayweather/Mosley. Probly Mayweather

 

Maybe not when it comes to in ring action but the hype and everything would make it 1 of those fights you think about exclusively for the week leading up and feel nerves the day of the fight. or else just me

 

rank both winners at number 1.5 with no clear p4p king.... that will send them on a collision course.

 

WHats that got to do with anything? Lewis beat every man he faced and retired on top, by your logic, he should still be top when he comes back, afterall no one has beaten him to knock him off the top spot. Its as if the boxing world stood idle whilst he went into retirement

Thats bull**** theory right there. First off no guarantee Floyd is favourite, in fact I thought Vegas had Pac favourite. Secondly what does favourite have to do with it? 18/20 Ring experts picked DLH to murder Pac...yes we go by assumptions rather than accomplishments.

P4P is POUND 4 POUND. Just 3 years ago Pac was fighting FWs, the mere mention of him taking on a top 5 WW is laughable. Now he's favourite against most of them. Pound 4 pound, that explains everything...he is the smaller man demolishing the bigger guys.

 

This