Who's Greater: Roberto Duran or Muhammad Ali?

Unless you`re suggesting Ali had parkinsons in fights before he met Holmes then what you`re saying is wrong, after Ali beat Foreman 50% of his fights were awful.

 

Ali is a top 3 atg duran isn't.
1.SRR
2.Armstrong
3.Ali

 

Ali beat better guys, whatever that is worth.

 

Charles is a top 10 atg but imo not greater than Ali but greater than duran

 

No. It isn't

 

Duran by a couple or few places, for me. If they're not reasonably close on your atg list then you should have another look at it.

 

He beat Calzaghe. Slappy Joe couldnt throw a legitimate punch he slapped like a girl. He'd have been DQ'd back in the old days when gloves were laced. They used to call it hitting with the inside of the glove or lacing

 

I am pretty sure he did. He was diagnosed at age 42, but it was determined that the onset was mid-thirties.

You might want to research it a little better.

 

Yeah & he meant ALI when he said that !! Ken said after the fight Duran hit him with every possible foul throughout the fight so he had to retaliate when he could the ref was just ignoring the fouling

 

Ali had early signs of Parkinsons right after the Thrilla in Manilla THATS when he should have retired. Ali beat Foreman mentally he made him punch himself out. Larry said he knew from round one that wasnt the real Ali in there but just a shell

 

Yes, they found scars on Ali`s brain after the Shavders bout and his speech and hand movements became slower.

 

Ali was #1 thats for sure. Plus that was after he was banned for over 3 years for purely political reasons. They tried every way to get Ali out. He came back after 31/2 yrs not quite the same Ali but STILL wayy above most of the others. Imagine what he would have achieved without the 31/2 year layoff