Why is AA so overrated??

I have no case. You suck though. :deal :hat

 

Where did I say he is over rated?

 

This statement just proves the utter stupidity that you as a human being possess. My first statement if you go back in this thread of yours had nothing but appreciation for Direll's performance against Arthur and how I thought Direll would be a hard fight for anyone from MW to LHW, thus disproving your statement about me as a nuthugger. Next, your ignorant, uneducated classless self, not even a ****** would do, asked the same stupid question about who has AA fought, while I answered your question in detailed sequence and you replied with this dribble above.
I swear some posters on ESB are literally to stupid to even offend!:hi:

 

Being over rated does not mean AA sucks. It just means he is not the unstoppable beast some people try to turn him into. Bute, Kessler, and Pavlik would all beat him half to death and leave him slumped in a corner. Dirrell would beat him worse in a rematch. He can beat Froch and Green. He's probably 55/45 with Andrade.

 

you also think kelly pavilk can beat monzon and martinez isn't a good fighter.

AA isn't overrated most people agree he has a low work rate and flatfooted style that means mover or fighters with a high workrate will trouble him

 

Either provide a lnk to the Monzon statement, or shut the **** up.

And no, Martinez is not a great fighter. He has one decent win in his entire career. And that came against an opponent who logged the worst performance of his life.

Abraham is one of the most over rated fighters on the planet, and only those who are unwilling to investigate his career, and face reality believe otherwise.

 

Pavlik needs to come up in weight the right way, and not go in against Bute for his initial fight, hopefully we could see AA vs Pavlik at SMW one of these days.

Kessler is somewhat on the decline and his best days are past him, this will be proven beyond a reasonable doubt if AA is able to handle Froch. I had the Kessler Froch fight MUCH closer then the official cards but won't go into detail with that.

Bute beating the SMW version of Antonio Margarito does not prove anything. He has the goods that much is obvious though.

 

Of course you could not, it is not your fault though, you have no reason to be ashamed, blame your parents:rofl!

 

I was banned for a few days. Missed me -- didn't you:yep

 

His overall skills aren't necessarily overrated as many recognize his strengths and limits but his resume to date, and most importantly his status and place amongst the 168lbs boys is vastly overrated.

Dirrell, Ward, Bute & Kessler are all above Abraham in every way. The thing is...many here saw Abraham as the man to beat in the Super 6 prior to him fighting Andre Dirrell... That's mainly why he's said to be overrated !!

 

How can they be above Arthur in every way? All the above mentioned have been fighting at SMW throughout there respective careers while Arthur has officially been at SMW for 2 fights? Maybe that statement will be true if Arthur does bad in his next 2 fights, but I have to disagree.

Direll has the most natural talent from all the mentioned fighters but most question his heart.
Ward beat Miranda who has lost every time he has stepped up. Beat Kessler clearly but with questionable officiating regarding the 5 or 6 CLEAR headbutts that were not called or warned.
Bute has beaten Andrade twice?
Kessler is on a decline and is not the same fighter against Calzaghe.
Now I am not disagreeing on your statement nor am I in agreement, but I think after the Super Six, we will obviously find out a lot more then we know now about said fighters.

 

There's generally two things to consider when comparing different fighters :

Skill set & accomplishments.

So to answer your question as to how are they above Abraham ?....

Skill wise, Dirrell-Bute-Ward & Kessler are above Abraham as far as I'm concerned. In regards to being accomplished at 168lbs, I think you answered it very well yourself by basically stating that Arthur hasn't really proven much as a Super Middleweight himself with only 2 fights, one of which is beating a previous Middleweight like himself and the other being outclassed towards a UD loss.

Therefore, it's quite easy for me to say that right now, at this point, I see Abraham being rated behind the four guys mentioned above.

 

Fair enough.