The top one, because I'm still not convinced that he's a P4P great. Don't shoot the messenger! :rasta
If you believe that, I wasn't really thinking that way though. Don't really matter what names are the ones filled in. I don't think Pac could Tarver Mayweather though. I don't think he has that one punch KO in him vs a guy like Mayweather. I know he did it to Hatton but Hatton leads with his head. If he were to do anything it would be a TKO as Mayweather if hurt would have to much pride to take a Knee and if hurt enough would take on more punches standing up.
Not necessarily as even if you hate Mayweather its still possible you would like to experience him achieving something that you didn't think he could pull off by pulling out a masterful boxing performance. Some casual fans may like Mayweather but wouldn't mind seeing how someone would be able to catch him and put him out. It doesn't have to be a love or hate thing.