Would you score this round 10-8

Tony Lopez vs John John Molina
Looking for some opinions on how you guys score fights and what constitutes a 10-8 round without a KD.

Edit: round 5

At the 6:45 point of the below video Molina takes control of this round, how would you score this if you were the judge.

This content is protected

 

I just got done round 8 and I also scored round 5 10-8 the commentator scored it 10-9 but they were debating if some judges might score it 10-8 or 10-9.

I might start a thread series called you be the judge to see what posters think about certain rounds.

 

Which hometown decisions did you feel he got that he didn’t deserve?

I am rescoring some Lopez fights this week and curious what ones you think were unfair.

I just scored Lockridge I & II and Molina I and feel he earned all of those. But I have not gotten to Paez, Brian Mitchell I & II, Thobela I or Molina III yet.

 

Yeah Tony seemed to throw back over the final 20 seconds or so, but I felt it warranted being 10-8. I was just curious how others saw it. Thanks

 

I had him winning both Molina I & III

Just scored both this morning.

1 Molina could/should have won but he pulled an earlier DLH vs Tito tactic starting in round 6 and pretty much gave away 6-9. I had him up 4 pts after 5 which I scored 10-8 Molina it was so onesided. But I have him losing the final 7 rounds of which 12 was the only debatable round he could have taken IMO. I had him winning 4 rounds and one even. I guess you could make a case for a draw, but not sure how he can win that when you factor in his low blow deduction in 11.

In 3 man Molina fought brilliant in 1-3 but may have punched himself out he was setting such a fast pace. I had him sweeping those 3 rounds, but he got on his bike in 4 and in 5-8 he had slowed his pace noticeably and I felt Lopez took 4-8 to go up 2 pts. I didn’t score 8 10-8 Lopez even though the commentary did and it would certainly be justified. It was close to 10-8 but I scored it 10-9 Lopez nonetheless. Molina came out jabbing in 9-10 and edged 2 super close rounds on my card to tie the fight up. But Lopez overwhelmed him in 11 and scored a huge KD to seal the round and pretty much the fight IMO. I gave Lopez a close 12th but even if I went even or Molina Lopez still would have won my card by a point or 2.

I think Pacheco started this narrstive during the 2nd Molina fight saying no way should he have lost the first fight after sweeping the first 6 rounds...to me it would be hard to say he won 1-6, I had him up 3-2-1 with 2 10-8 rounds...you might be able to argue 4-2 but not 6-0 like the imbecile Pacheco was.

I do think Lopez got a favorable draw to Brian Mitchell in the first fight and Thobela in the first fight by memory, but I have not rescored them yet. I think this is more one of those narratives that gets promoted by commentators that becomes a semi-fact in observers opinions. I don’t think it is fair to Lopez who fought great in these 2 Molina fights.

 

Lopez vs Molina cards
https://www.boxingforum24.com/threa...-watch-today-scorecard-thread.186016/page-339

Edit: last post on page 339 and first 2 on 340